Rules, Regulations and Moderation For Cred Forums - Results

ATTENTION Cred Forums!! The results are here. Which means this is officially the last meta thread and there is no more need for more. Mods, send this to Hiro. These are the new rules.

----

Hiro has asked us to create a thread on each board for discussing the problems that are facing us and how to deal with them. He also wants us to create our own set of rules so that the mods will be regulated to follow them.
Source: i.4cdn.org/a/1474181914334.png (embed)

Remember mods, Hiro talked to you guys and you said it was fine to have one ongoing thread up about this.

Other urls found in this thread:

strawpoll.me/11252112
witcheffect.com/mal/
docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSe32vRUAcgA4SSywCinEhWVLu2izTk84Po6FNp-p88SM9YNeg/viewform
docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSf5YEAXjpYrOTcxfHMtXBi_9kCZVqGqGSmfQ3Ugmy4wzJhjAw/viewform
youtube.com/watch?v=5LNHYz89sNc
youtube.com/watch?v=g8rVp9rwaS0
youtube.com/watch?v=ND8IIKwuPks
youtube.com/watch?v=TwcDRPBMMZY
youtube.com/watch?v=z2_dhUv_CrI
desuarchive.org/a/search/tripcode/!!WPtNxxXTYXX/
desuarchive.org/r9k/statistics/image-reposts/
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

...

Kill yourself.

Hiro doesn't trust polls, with good reason.
Get your false polls out of here proxy spammer.
Check em.

End your life.

I honestly think we should just stay the way it is now

If dubs I'm king of the universe

>tfw no dubs

>no mention of generals
Who made this shitty, retarded poll?

The REAL poll here.
strawpoll.me/11252112

...

I wouldn't put it past that nipnog to take this faggot seriously.

99

>implying Hiro will change the rules just from a single poll

Get the fuck out of here. Also, check 'em.

DUBS COME TO ME

Pretty decent choices.
Sasuga Cred Forums for actually pulling your shit together.

sticky trap threads when

Why is she so stupid?

>some shitty poll made during the time America (the only group of posters that matter) was asleep
I'm sure these results will be accepted 100% OP

can we get all of the options?

...

>allowing Korean shit on Cred Forums
Every single one of you who voted for that can burn in hell

...

Make Digibro a mod.

Why don't we make /ag/ - Anime and Manga Generals?

RULES OF BIG GUY

It should have been separated form LNs. LNs should be on here.

Wont help.
Look at Cred Forums

lol

Kill yourself my man

Why don't we make a containment website for all the normalfag boards? And if you post something there, you're automatically IP banned here

Generals are shit, they just turn into tripfag circlejerks.

Cred Forums improved and /vg/ did it's job.

Please look carefully at this image.

/gsg/ saved Cred Forums

Cripplechan already exists.

>DJT
>Buyfag
>Sadpanda
>Drawfag

Best thing to do.
MAYBE allow Light Novels, as one user pointed out, they're adapted into animu en masse now, so it would make sense to at least allow the ones that got adapted.

Perma-Ban anyone who starts a Thread after a SHAFT made show.

Fuck off you pathetic manchild.
You're no different than an autist screaming over someone to get them to stop talking about things which offend you.

>Hiro tells people they can have some meta discussion, as long as it stays in one thread
>retarded anons think that means it's okay to have a meta general

I'm going to have to agree with
on this one. meta-shitters need to get the fuck out. You make ONE thread when there's AN issue plaguing the board. moot axed /q/ for a reason

...

>I HATE GENERALS!
>alright so lets remove them from Cred Forums and put the elsewhere
>NO!

>ban all Marvel threads but keep the DCEU ones. Those are Kino threads.

Kill yourself already, crossboarding scum.

yeah if I want discussion I go to /tg/
if i need drama and shitpost and go to Cred Forums

Please elaborate.

neat

Permaban ESLtrash

...

This is chance to get manga board guys.

I've been on Cred Forums likely longer than you've had access to an Internet connection, you fucking pathetic manchild.

So this is Waifu and Sadpanda Board then?
Or instead of one One Piece thread we rather have a dozen?

t.alex

An empty manga board.

...

see

Why do you think that?

Time Mage? Fuck it, I'll just pick the one I like best screw your numbers. Which is obviously Archer. Or maybe Thief or Dancer or Mimics.

...

Just give people ips

roll

...

Kill yourself, cancer.

This isn't Cred Forums. America and Americans are entirely irrelevant on Cred Forums.

roll

...

...

...

t. HPM
Am I doing it right?

Show me where you mentioned strawpoll which is totally not exploitable.

Check these digits.

...

If you want to fix this board once and for all, bring it back to how it was in 2010 and earlier.

Elitism
tell new anons to lurk and understand the board culture before posting, dont allow Naruto and variants, Bleach and other entry level shows to have threads.
never spoonfeed but rather let them learn on their own.

We need a manga board, a pre 2000 anime board, and a LN/VN/others(korean shit for example) board.
>inb4 fuck off
Yeah sure, people are giving solutions to all our problems but noooo, nobody want solutions.

...

Shit poll.
Saged. I have to tell you that, because someone removed the e-mail field.

Forget about Cred Forums, the first thing that needs to happen is getting rid of the current mod team.

Remove Cred Forums from the front page and board list.

checked

Because plenty of manga threads here die quickly already. Splitting people's attention is going to cause even less participation.

*where he

...

>this certain user hopelessly triyng to derail the thread

You can still sage, put it in the options field.

Use your words, you insecure faggot.

>meme mod
In what game?

SLEEP TIGHT REN-CHON
Those who voted for the second and third options on there can get out. Maybe LNs since a bunch of anime are based on them, but that's it.

We shall see.

Sleep tight, Ren-chon

Sleep tight Ren-chon

There already is a board for korean shit. It's called Cred Forums
There already is a board for LNs and VNs. It's called jaypee.
There already is a board for all the cancer generals. It's called /vg/.

Ban Cred Forumsedditors from the board, political shit, porn spammers, videogame related shit, and black cock threads.

Everything will be fine if you do this.

It would be a naturally slower board.
Threads die on Cred Forums because they get pushed off by generals, anime, and meme threads.

Ban Cred Forumsedditors too.

I literally have no idea what I just said, I only know it somehow relates to your general.
t.kojak

I know I can, but you wouldn't know I did.

you and me user

This, but with a bit more moderation if possible. However, no matter how shitty Cred Forums's mods are, they're still amongst the best on the site. It's a miracle this place hasn't devolved into Cred Forums-tier garbage yet.

It's funny how all the generalfags will use
>just ignore it
as a defence, yet they are incapable of having others discuss the state of Cred Forums without them coming in and completely shitting up the thread. Cred Forums will keep degrading over time as long as these post-2007 faggots are allowed to be catered to.

...

Why shouldn't entry level shows be allowed? Hipster fuck

pleb
Cred Forums bros are welcome in Cred Forums

No, redditors are not welcome here.

Generals for video games, not anime and manga you twat

...

Can we have Black Clover general.

...

...

Mod Lelouch. Cunts been here long enough to know how shit should be.

>has a general to complain about generals.

Live action stuff is allowed here so why shouldn't LNs and Korean shit be allowed?

mods delete this thread
there's already a meta thread and Hiro doesn't take polls anyway

You don't understand. This Chinese cartoon has honestly changed my life.

I went into it not expecting much, considering that it had negative hype and looked utter shit. But holy fucking shit, was I totemo blown away. I was hooked, like a ninja to a bento box full of freshly prepared sushi. I could feel the energy and hype flowing through my tamashii, bringing light to my dull life. I resonated with Kenji. I could feel his struggle and his desire to make ninjas perish, something that struck me hard, as my family too were killed in a realistic fire explosion overlay. And then everything suddenly stopped when I heard the words:

"YEAAART!"

and I started trembling. That was me, I realised I've been slowly "Reciting my Death Haiku" over the course of these past years even though I have so much more time on this beautiful chikyuu. I haven't been able to hold a steady job, my grades were starting to slip, and my parents suspect that I'm gay. Would I get a chance to even compose a death haiku, or would I be forced to sayonara as my life was cut short, wasting my chance to leave a legacy behind? It was right then and there that I knew that I had to get my shit together. I can't think of any other anime that has had such a profound effect on me, let alone on the first episode. Tomorrow, I'm going to be a better man. Arigatou to you, Ninja Slayer, domo thank you Trigger.

I will become a Ninja that Kills the Ninjas that hide within my heart, and build a path towards becoming a great man.

Well then, how about getting rid off real problems like generals and meme threads then?

Anyone who voted for 2 should just go back to plebbit

Because the generals circlejerks are too big to get them voted off the island

When it comes to screening girls for the purposes of a committed, monogamous relationship in which you will be committing significant amounts of time, money and emotional capital to one woman, her past matters. A lot.

You will hear otherwise from delusional women who have been pumped and dumped yet are still hoping to attain commitment from a decent man, and from white knights who falsely believe that agreeing with an irrational female perspective might get them a scrap of pussy thrown their way. From these people you will hear that if you care about a girl's past you are insecure, have jealousy issues and an inflated male ego. Bullshit. There are perfectly logical reasons why a rational, well-adjusted man would want his woman to have a clean sexual history:

1. Past behavior is the best predictor of future behavior. It's not a perfect predictor. Some people do reform. But its the best indicator we have. If a girl has fucked a lot of guys in the past, she'll probably fuck a lot of guys in the future. This means cheating risk, or the risk that she will end your relationship on a whim because she finds another guy she wants to fuck. And it goes deeper. Has she ever cheated on a past partner? If so, you'll get cheated on. Does she accuse her exes of abusing her, but is sketchy on the details? If so, she'll be telling people you abused her when you break up. Past sexual dalliances and relationship problems generally predict a future of the same.

2. For every sexual partner a girl has, her capacity to emotionally bond to her next sexual partner decreases. So the less sexual partners a girl has had, the more deeply she will be able to fall in love with you.

To keep faggots like you out

Threads die on Cred Forums because people don't post in them, splitting the already tiny board in half won't solve anything.

3. Nobody wants to treat somebody else's whore like a princess. If a store is giving away free milk to every one else, and then tries to charge you full price, would you pay it? Could you walk to your car after purchasing your milk, and see all the people who got free milk smirking at you for being a sucker because they got the same enjoyment out of the same milk for free? Simply put, a girl puts a price on her vagina. If it's too high (no sex until marriage!) nobody will pay it, if it's low then why would you outbid anyone else?

4. A big one: Baggage. The more partners a girl has, the more likely she is to have baggage, aka lingering feelings, past lovers coming out of nowhere to threaten your relationship, conflicting relationships in social circles you have to deal with, etc. Its not a small amount of relationships that end due to issues like this. Even if you think all the other reasons are bullshit, you ignore this one at your own peril.

5. STD risk (obvious). And don't skim over this. Many people don't even know they have herpes, as crazy as that sounds. Your slutty girlfriend could be one of them.

6. A girls sexual past shows her general character and emotional stability. Did she rebound by fucking guys because she had to feel pretty and wanted? Did she seek out a lot of bad boys, older men, rich guys, whatever? Does she use guys for validation because she has a hole in her soul? Is she fucking only boyfriends, or does she have a history of fucking cool guys who won't commit to her? These things matter.

7. To make a relationship great, you want to be the best she has ever had. We evaluate the quality of sexual experiences based on previous sexual experiences. It is unfair to both of you if your sex pales in comparison to someone from the past. Doesn't a woman want to be the best her man has ever had? It is completely valid to want such a thing.

Fuck those who voted for the second one.

When a girl starts racking up partners, even in the context of a string of (failed) monogamous relationships, you have to understand there's a reason she either can't hold a man long-term, or continually gives in to her own impulses, or doesn't WANT to hold a long-term man, which is totally fine and a reason you shouldn't be considering her for monogamous commitment anyway.

But no matter which way you cut it, sluts just plain aren't good in the context of a LTR.

But "Muh feelings."

You should worry about your own board, Cred Forums.

witcheffect.com/mal/
If you're on the spectrum and have a MAL, check this out for some charts, graphs, and deeper filtering of your list.

No, they really aren't.

>Make a thread about rules and regulations
>It's nothing but shitposters and crossboarders
Sasuga

Sleep tight awoo.

Ban all generals

Is it okay to post cute sleeping girls?

>no manga board
>ban underage b8
>Allow LNs
>let Cred Forums remain Cred Forums
>get good mods
These results aren't even bad, niggas

A whole bunch of posts just got deleted.
A lot of the shitposting was one autistic user, likely a generalfag, afraid of people saying bad things about his general.

>lol will be a bannable offense
lmao kys you stupid redditor

As always:

MODERATE THE BOARDS.

99% of problems could be solved by removing bad threads and posts. It's just that simple.

No, we need to remove the generals.

Fucking kill yourself OP, meta posting is cancerous as fuck. Why do mods allow this faggotry?

Shh.

he is the mod

>More moderation
Yay, just what we dont need

Fuck off pleb

Until generals are removed, moderation is all but ornamental. It's like cleaning up the clothes strewn on the floor while leaving the huge pile of shit in the corner of the room.

This would be solved if we had board specific mods who have been in those boards for a decent amount of time.

Fuck you nigger.

This

Why do you feel so threatened by anons talking about moderation?

Until we hear from Hiro,I'm taking all this shit with a grain of salt. More mods are an awful idea.

Remove generals and remove global mods.

Generals delenda est

This looks comfy as fuck

Just filter them and you won't notice the """"cancer"""" ever again.

>mods cleaning up the thread instead of deleting it

This shit takes me back.

I'm conflicted about removing general threads in here , would it be better to remove generals in exchange of gorillion post about said X general i.e capeshit and GoT at Cred Forums

Spoken like a true general faggot

...

>Don't merge Cred Forums
So which general that banned now?

Jesus no. Everything on /vg/ is cancer, and if you try to discuss anything anything on Cred Forums that has a general on /vg/, you'll be redirected to /vg/ and the thread on Cred Forums is likely to get deleted. /vg/ is where good discussion goes to die, and it's inclusion stifled legitimate threads on Cred Forums.

That said, Cred Forums did have a problem with way too many threads on one topic, and /vg/ was made to solve that issue. Cred Forums doesn't have this problem. Yes, we have ongoing threads like Sad Panda or Buyfag or even what are essentially generals like Danganronpa, but they're essentially self contained and self regulated.

We don't have the same problem as Cred Forums, where Generals are a different beast and often have very little to do with the show they're supposed to be about. On Cred Forums, a general will continue well after new content stops coming out, and 90% of discussion will be circle jerking and blogging. On Cred Forums, that behavior is stamped out the moment it shows up. If you try to blog about your collection in a Buyfag thread, you're going to get shat on or ignored. And Danganronpa threads will naturally die out once the series finishes airing.

We don't need /ag/.

>killing Cred Forums

Shut the fuck up

>11th thread where people keep saying to leave Cred Forums like it is and don't fuck shit up
>nahh let's make a new thread in name on Hiro
Here's my tip, drink some HCl.

The death of people below me doesn't concern me. I do not cry for the cockroaches of this world. The only death that matters is the death of my darkness.

...

We don't need more boards, we need fewer users.
>prevent the site from being used by cellphones
>categorically ban any ip address sending requests to reddit, tumblr, and/or facebook
>bring back the original noko behavior, potentially with default autosage

>just hide the dog shit under the carpet and you won't notice it ever again

>tfw i actually drank some extremely diluted oxalic acid on hangover

It would probably be about the same really. We have a gorillion generals in Cred Forums.

whats a noko?

>splitting the already tiny board in half won't solve anything.
Why do people think Cred Forums is "tiny board"?

>original noko behavior,
so much of this

That's a terrible comparison and you know it.

It's like screaming for the government to cure the flu when you can just get a vaccine, why should you care if you don't have to deal with it anymore?

We don't need more than one fucking thread and thank fuck this is the last one. These threads are meaningless just like the old shitty /q/ threads that used to pop on here when moot was about. All they do is destroy board culture for the sake of the minority of cunts who actually go into these cancerous threads.

Fuck off with your meta generals already.

Defending their generals.

This isn't even a sticky, Hiro doesn't give a shit about that poll.

>/ma/ - manga
Whose insanity gave birth to this ridiculous idea?

Also ban newfriends like this fellow.

Generals aren't nearly as big a problem as everyone makes them out to be. It's just another thread like any other that you have to ignore while scanning the catalog. I couldn't give less of a shit what goes on in the generals or how much shitposting there is. I will never visit them after all.

"Spillover" of generalfags into other threads is another non-argument since these people will be here regardless of whether generals exist or not.

No, generals do not attract newfags either. This is a myth. You really think people posting in generals are newfags? No, they are seasoned shitposters and they are posting where they belong. The more posts they make in their general, the less posts they make in threads I actually visit.

The problem no one realizes is that it's not the threads themselves that are the problem; it's the people making and posting in the threads. No matter how hard you try, these people are here to stay. They will still be shitposting among you even if they stop making/posting in generals. I'd much rather let them post in their generals than have all generals banned and have these people post in threads I actually visit (at least to a higher extent than they already do).

>what are immune problems?

>bring back the original noko behavior
THIS

THIS PLEASE

>Cred Forums exceptionalism
Cred Forums generals are just as shitty you deluded faggot

sage = do not bump, takes to front page
age = bump and to front page (default)
noko = bump and back to thread
nokosage = no bump and back to thread

whats a newfriend?

see

...

Fucking this. These threads only create meaningless drama.

this

> chinese and korean shit invading like they invaded JapanExpo

Prepare to abandon board.

Requires login:
docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSe32vRUAcgA4SSywCinEhWVLu2izTk84Po6FNp-p88SM9YNeg/viewform

Requires no login:
docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSf5YEAXjpYrOTcxfHMtXBi_9kCZVqGqGSmfQ3Ugmy4wzJhjAw/viewform

>moot asks about making manga board
>anons now insist it's an idea only newfags would think of
We need manga board!

Good job making this place worse like usual Hiro.

(you)

Yeah from here all the boards are predertemined to become Cred Forums or Cred Forums with only a 24 hr circlejerk of certain memes. I even would dare to say that once the presidential elections are over the site in general is going to improve, a lot, too much negative attention and /pol crossboarders.

ban spoonfeeding faggots

You made a fucking shit poll.

Well considering this is an anime website and Cred Forums has just over half the posts per minute Cred Forums does it's not too much of a stretch to consider it tiny.

>introduce board based mods
>Implying we want to deal with small town mentality

global mods prevent local cliques from squeezing the life out of a board.

>Ban "pointless" threads like "This is your X tonight" threads and Cowtits/Flat threads?
yes please, half the board is this and generals

Still relevant today, except its on all boards now

But i's contained cancer. It was so bad that gave birth to /vp/ and Cred Forums.

We nee a manga board because people here are harassing mangafags.

You can keep spouting this shit but you'll never provide an actual reason to ban generals other than generals having exclusive memes which is a thing for every single anime anyway.

By no stretch is Cred Forums a tiny board.
There's only a small number of faster boards. Cred Forums is a fast board.

>Generals aren't nearly as big a problem as everyone makes them out to be.
Yes they are.
Fucking kill yourself, generalfag.

>JoJo
>Danganronpa
>Monmusu
>Yugioh
>OPT
>Sadpanda
>Macross
>/ak/
>Re:Zero
>KanColle
>Buyfag
>DJT
>Drawfag
>HeroAca
>One Piece
>Love Live
>Schwarzesmarken
>SnK
>Precure
These are all the generals on Cred Forums right?

Nice, let's get rid of "off topic" shit before the main problem that is shitposting, fucking nice.

Local mods preserve the board culture. There's no way global mods can understand every board.

>but you'll never provide an actual reason to ban generals
Because they don't fucking belong on a website which is based entirely around anonymity and ephemeral discussion, you fucking idiot.

The burden of reason is on the generalfags to argue that their cancerous shitholes belong here, as their very nature runs fundamentally counter to the entire design of the website.

I guess tiny was the wrong word, it is pretty small among the relevant boards though, you'd think it'd be around the same scale as Cred Forums considering this is an anime website with crossover with every board but nope, they're over twice as big.

>We
No, you just need to kill yourself.

That's about right, and half the fucking board.

Don't forget all the seasonal shows that have continuous back to back threads

/ai/ too

Nope, sorry to burst your bubble kiddo, but read this
>The problem no one realizes is that it's not the threads themselves that are the problem; it's the people making and posting in the threads. No matter how hard you try, these people are here to stay.
and tell me why I'm wrong. Go ahead, I'll wait.

Live action adaptations of anime and manga, you nigger.

Why would you use strawpoll instead of a google forms survey?

Shitposting exists because there are threads which act as shitposting grounds. Template threads and generals are such grounds.

Either explain how generals fit into the scheme of thread design on Cred Forums or fuck off back to your cancerous general.

Those were listed.

Saying generals are against the design of the website is fucking stupid when there's names, tripcodes, passworded tripcodes, and even a fucking board for generals.

And I guess the point about ephemeral discussion is somewhat valid but you must be really naive if you think that was ever a thing on any board, people don't just discuss something once pack up their bags and leave, especially on a board based around a medium with so little to discuss that hasn't been discussed to death already.

ara ara~~
little manga-kun needs a diaper change again??

you cant poo every hour, i dont even feed you that much ;^)

Why should that matter? If we were allowed to discuss anything distinctly rooted in anime or manga we'd able to talk about certain VNs too.

>No matter how hard you try, these people are here to stay.
Not if you remove their generals, which allows them to behave like fucking idiots entirely unmoderated.

>And I guess the point about ephemeral discussion is somewhat valid
It is the underlying point, you fucking moron. Tripcodes, names, and secure tripcodes in no way undermine the ephemeral of threads and topics like generals do.

Now either explain how generals fit into the scheme of thread design on Cred Forums or fuck off back to your cancerous general.

Summary from last thread:

1. Improve consistency of guidelines from board to board. Threads about our anime/manga collection and what we should watch next are considered "blogging" here and deleted/banned, but similar threads (collections and recommendations) are acceptable on other boards, like /k/. Inconsistent application of guidelines leads to confusion and resentment, especially when sneaky moderation tactics like "auto-sage" are used on threads that have not yet hit any bump limits.

2. Mods should stop abusing short bans and should take ban appeals more seriously instead of blanket denying/blocking all appeals with no transparency.

3. Bring back ability to delete own OP on all boards, eliminate requirement to delete posts before they become "too old to delete."

4. Bring back OP's ability to bump own threads. The unique IP meter is a good enough indicator of samefagging. There is no need to prevent OPs from bumping their own threads.

5. Bring back visible sage and educate people what it means.

6. Bring back ability to announce reports and sages.

7. Mods should stop micro-managing conversations by deleting short shitposts that no one cares about and which don't actually disrupt the thread.

8. Bring back a /z/ board where people can go if they are banned for infractions other than CP and post with no rules or post-timers.

9. Bring back /l/ where we can post lewd loli images. Trying to make /l/ threads work on Cred Forums is like being marooned on a desert island. Spam and non-enthusiasts filling the thread make for a bad environment, and the speed that Cred Forums moves means that threads die quickly and few /l/olikons hang around long.

10. Eliminate SFW requirement on Cred Forums. A lot of anime and manga isn't safe for work. Sometimes you need to post a nude image or lewd doujin to appreciate the original work. We shouldn't have to spoiler every lewd image and other people shouldn't be browsing Cred Forums from work anyway.

Global mods are bound to be newfags, local mods can be screened and trusted to actually somewhat understand the board as well as better understand what could be considered off-topic.

Manga is being oppressed by anime.

>gook shitt and chink shit on Cred Forums
Fuck no, i will never allow this shit

>scheme of thread design
Is this supposed to mean something? I was unaware you were some authority on how thead posting on Cred Forums works. Oh wait, you're not.

I don't think general threads are such a bad idea. It's logical step once a site has grown too much, certain people might just want to talk about a single thing, and keep the really weird, annoying people in one place.
I'm always amazed the amount of rule 34 and gay pornography in almost every general.

Meh, it will work for a while this has happened before, kinda, and it didn't work for long i don't know why you guys are so exited about this.

>gook and chink shit
>rooted in anime and manga
What the fuck is this retard talking about?

>People wanting to delete generals
Do you even remember why Kill la Kill needed a sticky when an ep came out?

Here's what happens when you have global mods.

You mean
>my opinions from last thread

How can you forget the biggest of them all?

the porn game

I've never bought this shit. It's not like Cred Forums is some lightning fast chat board, it takes about an hour to go off of page ten even in the busy parts of the day. That means an hour without a single person replying to your thread. That's not being "pushed off" unfairly or anything, that's just a thread rightfully falling off the catalog because no one wants to discuss the manga in question. Making a manga board won't introduce more people who want to discuss that shit, and it certainly won't lead to more threads for most series, they'll just get maybe one or two more replies before dying, when they do get made. It will be a board of generals and dead threads.

Don't be fucking dense.
Threads are supposed to be created spontaneously and die in the same manner.
Generalfags are actively fighting against this design by keeping their threads alive as long as possible then proceeding to remake the thread the moment it dies, entirely irrespective of whether or not there is something to discuss.

>Oh wait, you're not.
I know how Cred Forums works and the fact that Cred Forums functioned just fine without generals, for years. Now, unless you have an actual reason as to why your cancerous little hugboxes have a valid place on Cred Forums, you can fuck right off back to one of them.

I've seen several posters in big 3 threads admitting they only come to Cred Forums for those threads

BTFO

>10. Eliminate SFW requirement on Cred Forums.
Please don't. I much prefer SFW boards since they have less idiots starting threads with 3DPD or posting unspoilered lolishit which is illegal in my country.

Spoilering an image is not difficult, and people that don't care about spoilers can have them disabled by default.

if anything I think Cred Forums needs less strict rules for posting about anime/manga

if i don't have the right to shitpost a board to death, then what rights do I have?

You have warped sense of how fast Cred Forums is because you only compare it to Cred Forums and a couple other very fast boards.
Medium speed boards have good discussion over the course of hours.

Bananya is the best anime of this century. discuss

Why would we want Korean garbage here?

Also, if janitors actually nuked the obvious bait posts this would be one of the better media based boards.

I'm pretty happy with Cred Forums as it is right now desu.

Move the following:
Japanese learning general to either /jp/ or Cred Forums
Buyfag general to /toy/.
Drawfag general to /ic/.
Exhentai general to one of the handful of porn boards.
Image dump threads to either /c/ or outright delete them.
Seiyuu 3DPD worship threads to /jp/.

With those gone, all that remains is actual Cred Forums content to moderate. Sure, there are other shitty threads but first thing is first: getting rid of shit which outright belongs on other boards.

You have the right to kill yourself

b-but muh board culture

>It is the underlying point, you fucking moron. Tripcodes, names, and secure tripcodes in no way undermine the ephemeral of threads and topics like generals do.
I never said they did.

>Now either explain how generals fit into the scheme of thread design on Cred Forums or fuck off back to your cancerous general.
Thread design? What the heck are you talking about? This isn't some forum with a hundreds of rules, most of the rules here are decided by the community and the community wants generals, if they didn't there wouldn't be generals on every single board. Do you really think it'd be better to have multiple threads for the same series each discussing something different when they could keep it contained in one thread? It's not like just putting general in the title suddenly makes everyone start shedding everything they know about how to act on this site.

If you're so triggered by something the community obviously wants go and make your own website.

People have been asking for general threads to be sent away or deleted for 6-7 years and even though there was a brief period of pushback in 2011, mods and the board eventually realized that the board, in its current form, makes more sense if we allow general threads. There are a lot more people here now and even with post timers and captchas, a thread can progress very quickly with still more conversation in the next thread.

We don't need an /ag/ for generals only, but we could solve a lot of problems some people have of Cred Forums topics being too restrictive if we just separated /ac/ - "current airing anime and manga," with Cred Forums "anime, manga and other anime-related topics." Even doing that, though, is risky. Board balkanization tends to kill discussion on one of the boards, and is rarely a good thing overall.

leave Cred Forums alone fuckers

the more regulations and moderation bullshit we have the less fun it'll be

we are already in a OC drought, do you want to completely wipe it out?

It doesn't matter if lewd loli is unspoilered or not. If your nanny state government decides to investigate you, the fact that you visit Cred Forums.org is proof enough that you are a depraved pedophile.

reading comprehension

>board based mods
literally the best suggestion ever.

in fact, no site-wide mods should exist.

just get enough regular browsers for each board to moderate it.

>Saying generals are against the design of the website is fucking stupid when there's names, tripcodes, passworded tripcodes, and even a fucking board for generals.
But you did?

What's wrong with the Stella posts?

this. Fuck generals!

>>we are already in a OC drought
That's because mods are too strict with the range of topics allowed here. OC threads are simply deleted on sight for not being related to a specific anime or manga, killing a lot of potentially interesting and fun conversation.

Hence why we are having this conversation.

you forogt to move the kancolle general to Cred Forums it's a GAME with an anime adaptation no one talks about.
I personally believe that once a show based on a game should only be allowed on Cred Forums for another season before it becomes Cred Forums / /vg/ territory

I'm not comparing it to anything, I don't visit other boards. That's my judgment in a vacuum.

> have good discussion over the course of hours
That has literally nothing to do with what I said. Cred Forums has good discussion over the course of hours, too. Most threads probably last four hours+, and some last two days. We're talking about threads that don't get discussion.

Unless you mean "over the course of hours" as in multiple hours between posts, but any board that has threads with hours between average posts that get more than 30 replies total is certainly not "medium speed".

and gook chink shit to /trash/

>Thread design? What the heck are you talking about? This isn't some forum with a hundreds of rules, most of the rules here are decided by the community and the community wants generals, if they didn't there wouldn't be generals on every single board
Thread design, as in how the fucking imageboard software operates. There is a reason why Cred Forums became an ephemeral anonymous image board and not another clone of SA, you fucking mong.

>If you're so triggered by something the community obviously wants go and make your own website.
This is exactly what generalfags need to do. You're likely to fucking stupid to notice the massive amount of irony in someone like you making such a statement.

Now either explain how generals fit into the scheme of thread design on Cred Forums or fuck off back to your cancerous general.

They were spammed in Mari threads and Asterisk threads. It was spam.

>based entirely around anonymity and ephemeral discussion
>anonymity

Of course you would newfag. This is the most reddit and facebook friendly the board has ever been.

its a Scylla and Charybdis situation.
let up on moderation and then people abuse the hell out of it.

Fate threads are not continuous nor they have the fucking name on the the Subject field, therefore not generals.

If there's someone autistic enough to learn about the board culture of every single board, I think they should deserve the chance to become a site-wide mod.

Ban gayposting and tumblrshit outside of the Mugen fujo general.

Yes, allow LN/manwha/manhua.

The former being actually useful for Cred Forums discussions while the latter two will piss off a bunch of weaboos.

I say it's a win-win choice.

> OC threads are simply deleted on sight
Such as?

Moot just had really thin skin. We need to see what a Hiro administration would look like with Cred Forums in its original form.

Now address the rest of the point, you disingenuous fuck.

>allow manhwa and manhua on Cred Forums
Who is the fuckingn retard who made this shit? Fuck off, check my 7

We'll never know the true range because of how quickly they get deleted.

Only thing that should be changed is the newfag mods and the dogshit moderation in general.

Consider sudoku.

>being unable to tell shit posters like OP to kill themselves
So this is how reddit finally takes over Cred Forums.

>Thread design, as in how the fucking imageboard software operates.
Why would this matter when even the board for generals has a post limit?

>There is a reason why Cred Forums became an ephemeral anonymous image board and not another clone of SA, you fucking mong.
Because this is a clone of a Japanese website and Japanese people value anonymity.

>This is exactly what generalfags need to do. You're likely to fucking stupid to notice the massive amount of irony in someone like you making such a statement.
People who browse generals aren't the ones that are triggered, generals have been a huge part of the website for years now and no matter how much you scream it won't just disappear over night, there will always be threads about popular franchises and series.

>fuck off back to your cancerous general.
I don't even go to generals much, I just go to them every so often when I want to discuss part of the series they're discussing.

No one want gook trash here, weebs or not

>>allow manhwa and manhua on Cred Forums
>Who is the fuckingn retard who made this shit?
/qa/. They are filthy crossboarder garbage who doesn't actually know anything about Cred Forums culture.

no people do abuse it nowadays when given the chance, there was a point in time when we could have a nightly ronery thread, but allow that now and people would make realtionshit threads every hour(and they did), the demographics of Cred Forums has changed too much to allow a hands off moderation approach.

Is that Belmundo?

I'm asking for examples, nigger. We have an archive, you claim to have seen these OC threads get unjustly deleted, so show me some.

>while the latter two will piss off a bunch of weaboos.
it's still get shit on like normal, poor little gook

it's not in a hugbox way. it's in a "contributes just as little as the shitpost" way

Witnessed.

>categorically ban any ip address sending requests to reddit, tumblr, and/or facebook

You wouldn't be able to post here in that case.

Yeah, let's allow Western webcomics while we're at it, and cartoons, too. Because they're not Japanese, and weeaboos like Japanese things, so that means we should obviously allow non-Japanese things on the Japanese cartoon board.

PLEASE MODS IF YOU DO ANYTHING JUST FUCKING BAN ALL THE IMAGE DUMP THREADS LIKE THE TRAP GENERALS AND OTHER /h/ and /d/ FAP BAIT THREADS. SEND THE ASS THREADS TO SOME OTHER SEX ORIENTED BOARD

I can see this /qa/ faggot here

Can we all agree that generals are the only problem Cred Forums has right now?

Everything else is fine as it is.

No. There's also derp_commander.

generals are great!

Not the only problem but it's a major one.

That's not how it works. When you have a culture of board strangulation, banning people for even the slightest off-topic threads, it discourages other people from starting their slightly off-topic threads. OC threads do get deleted, but most OC threads simply don't get made anymore to begin with because people know that they will have their thread deleted after 150 posts with no explanation, so why even try. There's a reason we have regular OC on practically every other board besides Cred Forums.

Kill yourself, fuckface. Even if hiroshima allow your gook shit on Cred Forums, we will shit on it even more

sounds like shit

Just ban everything related to fujoshit/yurishit you will automatically ban all the shitposters too, they have their own boards and they need to fuck off.

Anyone who complains about Cred Forums or "racism," as if those are even problems with Cred Forums, are /qa/cks.

This guy gets it.

>claim something
>asked for evidence
>actually I meant something else
Okay.

yo yo yo check this dubs out

You have yet to give any examples of what you mean by OC. It's beginning to look like you made a blatantly off-topic thread and got asspained when it got deleted for being off-topic nonsense.

Fuck you. That is how it works, regardless of if your ignorant brain can understand or not.

...

I had the misfortune to see that autistic faggot in person. Instant permaban in my opinion.

No the old ways were way too autistic.

Dank dubs bro.

>doesn't even understand what OC is
You have no right to participate in the conversation, kiddo. Even on Cred Forums, they have threads where they draw or re-draw their meme frogs. We used to have threads like that where anyone could contribute, not just "drawfags." We no longer have those kinds of threads here.

You mean like all this battle shonen fags and loli virgins. Then yah

It's this autist again

>and facebook
have fun with one post an hour

Generals were never a problem, just autists getting triggered because they don't know how filtering works or can't stay out of a thread they don't like.

Cred Forums just needs mods to ban non Cred Forums related posts and purge generals.

>what is OS
Is this nigga for real

I would prefer it.

>Muh fanfic
Fuck back to tumblr

>implying
Just because you're a normalfag doesn't mean the rest of us are.

Not an argument.

and nothing of value was lost

>but most OC threads simply don't get made anymore to begin with because people know that they will have their thread deleted after 150 posts with no explanation
That's not the reason. The current majority on Cred Forums isn't able to create oc.

>let's just hide the dogshit under the carped instead of throwing it out, i'm sure there will be no consequences later

Not an argument.

>fanfic
I don't even know where to begin with you. Maybe a dictionary? You are part of the problem. OC threads are fun. You are just an idiot, though.

>/ar/
>/ag/
>/m/
No.

>Summary from last thread:
>and the one before that too
Kill your fucking self.

/ma/ makes no sense to make and unnecessarily splits the board. It's not like Cred Forums is fast like Cred Forums. If people want to discuss a manga, it can easily survive.

Post quality is very important here. Those words should get the same negative treatment that asking for sources does. As for posts that hurt peoples' feelings/trigger them with racism, tough luck. This is Cred Forums. Not a hugbox like tumblr. Just don't let autists on either side let it ruin threads. Local moderators could deal with autists on either side of that.

100% for LNs, and Manhwa/Manhua are pretty much manga with funny names. It makes no sense to not have LNs on Cred Forums when they are fundamentally tied to anime as much as manga is. Certainly moreso than the live action shows that people allow on Cred Forums. Using /jp/ is not an argument, because the /jp/ community overwhelmingly hates LNs and will spam or ignore any thread about them with the very rare exception for sometimes not outright attacking threads for LNs that have no English translation and no anime/manga adaptation.

Cred Forums does not and will not ever need to merge with any board. Simple as that.

Cred Forums most likely would benefit from board-based mods that know and appreciate our culture. Nothing like the lazy mods or SJW mods that sometimes come through here. Granted, I haven't noticed much faggotry coming from mods these days on Cred Forums. Just make sure to get mods that will delete generals on sight.

This is a pretty good suggestion as well. We could also really use a loli board, since Cred Forums is a normalfag shithole.

Well that is exactly what your parents did with you.

I am the dubs of my 7
Dubs is my body and trips is my blood
I have created over a thousand dubs
Unknown to Banned, Nor known to Life
Have withstood pain to create many dubs
Yet, those hands will never hold any trips
So as I pray, unlimited dubs works.

...

People can create OC on other boards, like Cred Forums. I think there are plenty of people on Cred Forums who can create OC.

...

>>/m/

We didn't have a dog though

Baneposting should be allowed everywhere on this board, it's moot's legacy by his own admission.

Yes, is an argument.

>and Manhwa/Manhua are pretty much manga with funny names.
This is the dumbest shit I've heard this month

>Manhwa/Manhua are pretty much manga with funny names
Have you seen fucking webtoons? They absolutely are not. You might as well argue to allow OEL manga or weeaboo webcomics, or Avatar/Wakfu/whatever.

not anime or manga related
tevee please go

If you filter the generals you don't have a way to discuss a series outside of it, since any thread you make will get replies telling you to go to the general instead.

You're not even touching on the worst part of generals: They create communities where people know each other which go completely against the "anonymous" culture of the website. You can go on some generals and see posts like "OMG it's that X guy coming to defend his waifu again, I know it's you because of the style of your posts. I had an argument on discord with this guy before and he is toxic! I was even talking about him with Y tripfag the other day..."

>SnK
I remember when this was just a random manga that Cred Forums liked. We would have a discussion thread here and there mostly talking about the actual manga. I tried to look into the general after the last chapter and I didn't even understand what the fuck they were talking about, it seems like it's entirely about romance (in a shounen manga of all things) and tribal shit like "Don't listen to xcharacterfags, they are salty because ycharacter is the best!".

>JoJo
I remember going into one of these generals and seeing a post "when did you first get into JoJo?" or something like that and some replies were like "I started watching anime last year!" or "I have never heard of it but my friends told me to watch it".

tl;dr: generals are cancer, and fuck anime adaptations for making fanbases shittier

you'd honeslty prefer absolutely no discussion than poor discussion
I don't use facebook I just realise that it's incredibly popular and I imagine 90% of the people here use it (although there's no reason responding to you because you're just going to accuse me of being a normie anyway)

>It makes no sense to not have LNs on Cred Forums when they are fundamentally tied to anime as much as manga is
What tied does gook and chink shit have with manga & anime?

Nice meme discussion.

Read these threads, There plenty more even more retarded crap here

I do not mean to be a bastard or a lel fuck off to reddit asshole.
But if you want a million different boards that cater to your specific needs that is what Reddit is for.

Generals go against what Cred Forums is about, at least give it a /got/ styled ban, if there is no new material then the generals get deleted.

For fuck sake restrain your autistic urges.
You sound like a fucking retard.

I technically am but I still don't want to see that crap. I've been here forever and I've never even gotten a letter from my ISP, so I should be fine.

But and are not.

>normie
Kill yourself, retard. /r9k/ isn't part of deciding rules for Cred Forums.

There's no way this isn't ironic. It's not this bad.

Fuck moot. Batman was like 5 years ago and baneposting was boring the first time it was done.

...

Gook shit is the most disgusting thing in the world

>normie
Why are you here? Who cares about fecesbook

What is (you)?

>Kill yourself, retard. /r9k/ isn't part of deciding rules for Cred Forums.
I'm literally quoting what the guy called me

Aren't Anime broadcasted through a Cred Forums? You got outplayed faget.

Serialized manhwa/manhua != webtoons, you fucking subhumans. Japs also pull that shit and we don't allow that either. Just don't allow low quality shit and post about actually good shit.

The board cannot be saved. The damage has been done through the years and the community does not want to change itself without moderator intervention

This is the kind of shitposting that can kill a board.

>and Manhwa/Manhua are pretty much manga with funny names
What the fuck? No wonder why gookboo are retard.

I'm all for OC but you have to understand that it's a vague term and if you were to allow that level of freedom, it would introduce a whole new level of shitposting cancer that might turn us into Cred Forums

take for example, the blue ribbons memes, it is so loosely related to anything that has to do with Cred Forums but the mods tolerate it because its been here for a decent amount of time and theres only one or two people that put effort into doing them so it's not that cancerous.

You're part of the problem.

No, you fucking aren't. He called you a normalfag, you blithering newfag crossboarder.

>"If you filter the generals you don't have a way to discuss a series outside of it, since any thread you make will get replies telling you to go to the general instead."

>Everyone doesn't shit up the board with 30 discussions about the same anime series

I don't see a problem with keeping all the retards in one thread, maybe you're part of them.

Normalfag ≠ Normie

>do i fit in yet?

I would rather spend my time interacting meaningfully rarely with people that matter, than have to continually wade through the retarded awful shit normalfags insist on bringing here, yes.

What low quality shit you're talkig about? And this is anime & manga board. Gook and chink shit are not manga & anime related, fuck off

>having to constantly scroll up the thread to see if one of my posts was deleted by a mod or jani for whatever random reason and it made the conversation nonsensical as a result

And this is one of the biggest things wrong with Cred Forums. Hiro, please fix.

> Serialized manhwa/manhua != webtoons
You didn't fucking mention "serialized," retard. Webtoons are a form of manhwa.

> Japs also pull that shit and we don't allow that either
Yes, we fucking do. It's called OPM. Or that Batou Shoujo shit from late last year. It just doesn't come up much because no one cares.

If all you read is shit, of course you'll think that everything is shit. Get some personal agency and think for yourself for once.

Make Cred Forums a red board and watch all the autists here sperg out about their sikret club getting drowned by porn threads.

The biggest problem here is that Cred Forums is slowly turning into tumblr and reddit. Way too many normies with autism and ausperger levels off the roof.

Fuck off. It's been in a steady decline, but has gotten shittier much faster over the last year or so.

>Cred Forums anime & manga
Fuck off with your bootleg gook trash, shitface

>chinese and korean animation allowed
>glorious soviet union isn't

youtube.com/watch?v=5LNHYz89sNc
youtube.com/watch?v=g8rVp9rwaS0
youtube.com/watch?v=ND8IIKwuPks
youtube.com/watch?v=TwcDRPBMMZY
youtube.com/watch?v=z2_dhUv_CrI

>if you were to allow that level of freedom, it would introduce a whole new level of shitposting cancer that might turn us into Cred Forums
We had this level of "freedom" until like 2014.

I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt and assume that you say that because I am defeatist and have not proposed any solutions or any contributions to the discussion. Not because of anything else that might make you sperg out

>If you filter the generals you don't have a way to discuss a series outside of it, since any thread you make will get replies telling you to go to the general instead.
Fucking this. You can't make your own fucking threads anymore its bullshit.

different demographics

you would have to genocide all the normalfags, crossboarders, and crosssiters to have the previous freedom we had

It's Cred Forums's fault. They recruit outsiders without doing background checks.

Cred Forums allows live action shit and general threads. That's already far worse than what the zipperheads shit out.

That won't happen, and if it did, it could be easily solved with a "no H image dumps" rule.

People need to be able to discuss lewd doujins alongside their anime and manga counterparts, even if we can't dump the whole thing, we should be able to post a sample page or two.

You know what, test all this shit about allowing LNs and gook shit for a month or so. What I expect will happen is that their threads will drown and go to page 10 against anime/manga discussion since the fanbase for those is way bigger. And then they will voluntarily request for their stuff to go into another board instead.

Yeah, can't wait for some bootleg gooktrash cucking my husband he is assasin with my chicken man who delivered kfc something, fuck off cunt

But it's already full on tumblr.

You get people getting triggered by someone saying "nigger" in basically every thread.

I'm here because it's the only place that I can have fun talking about anime
I don't really care about facebook, I just realise that if they got rid of everyone who used it (just under a quarter of the population of the world) I imagine a good chunk of posters would be gone and take both good and bad discussion with it
My bad, I hold my hands up. I don't follow the memes I don't use
so would I. I just reckon that more people than you'd like to imagine use facebook.

>different demographics
You have no evidence to support this claim and you know it.

>like Cred Forums
I'm not sure if you can count 994242th pepe-trump edit as oc.

Howdy gook, tell me something about your shitty manga ripoff

You don't have to be from Tumblr to get annoyed by edgelord children :^)

>Banning people for saying "fuck off" or "kill yourself"

What? Is this Cred Forums's newspeak? That's half of Cred Forums's vocabulary. You cant take away our words. Ill have no way to tell people off for disagreeing with my opinions.

we definitely have more human garbage on Cred Forums than previously

how can you deny that?

>gook
Anything that's not white is not alright. A Jap, a Gook, and a Chink are all the same shit.

I'm not asking what OC is, you fucking retards. said
>OC threads are simply deleted on sight for not being related to a specific anime or manga
and I'm asking for proof of this. Post links to these threads that were being unjustly deleted.

At least pay attention to the conversation before you post.

>words can be "edgy"

Look at this dumb nigger.

>your OC is just an edit of an edit of a repost of a repost

Welcome to pre-2012 Cred Forums. It was a fun time.

It hurts.
Do you even browse this board?

I can't believe someone just called me a nigger on Cred Forums, I'm literally shaking right now.

How can you assert it?

>live action from anime/manga
>anime/manga general
You make it sound like your gook shit isn't general when all you koreaboo do in there is circle jerking about how gookshit is better than 99% manga out there and spamming thread about gook shit

There was also another guide which was older than this one.

Just burn it all down.

>not knowing about the moe slice of life series
What are you, a fucking normalfag?

Now I feel bad, why are you being reasonable? It's not like such a change would ever be implemented, even in the case that it would be feasible to do so. This imageboard is meant to be open for everyone.

>mfw no matter what our chink overlord decides to do, gooks will start spamming their shitty webtoons because of proxypoll

thanks a lot you fucking asshole

Nigger.

>and Manhwa/Manhua are pretty much manga with funny names.
No. Only JP content should be here, which includes live action and of course LNs and VNs. LNs wouldn't work on /lit, VNs work on Cred Forums but that's still not a reason to have them here too.

DJT should also stay here, since it has been here for so long. Moving it to /jp/, where they might just have it deleted, is a bad idea. More people able to do translations is always a good thing, more people being able to not need translations is always a good thing. Buyfag threads could also go to /jp/ but it really doesn't matter.

Webtoons are 90+% of the chink/gook comics that get discussed, those are what we're talking about. no one's crusading against Ravages of Time or Veritas, or the like two other non-webtoons that get discussion that don't have Japanese publications anyway.

>Post links to these threads that were being unjustly deleted.
Who the hell saves links to every little thread that gets deleted over a 4 year period? I've been here the whole time, I've observed it happening.

Introduce /ma/- Manga please, I switched a long time ago and it keeps animeshitters away

Surely Hiro will go bankrupt soon.

NigNog.

Cred Forums is unironically better in terms of moderation.

Personal IDs make people more reclutant to shitpost in a thread to avoid looking like a recognizable retard.

Please mods just kill the imagedump threads that are just fapbait from the porn boards like /h/ or /d/

>muh ass
>muh cowtits
>muh traps and feminine penises

2000 characters of text is not evidence of a poster's demographics.

There are lots of x yourselves, so it's not like we'll run out of suggestions.

>gook ripoff Japan moe slice of life
Can gook do anything other than ripoff and get raped by the greatest nation in the world? Why are gook and chink so pathetic?

Remove 24/7 generals. Why hasn't this been done yet? They are just chatrooms.

As a primarily mangafag, the average mangafag on Cred Forums is an absolute piece of shit and I'd much rather hang out with animefags and read the occasional good manga thread that does pop up.

>one autistic general understanding the wishes of the entire board
Fuck no.

Read better manga

>attempting to start any thread on /c/
>attempting to start a SFW thread on /e/ or /h/
Good luck with that, then.

Nigger newfaggot

>moe slice of life series
I read enough of Japan moe slice of life series, i don't need some bottom tier bootleg trash from gook and chink land

I haven't been following these threads, but this elitism thing has bothered me for several years

There's no nice way to put it other than the simple truth that Cred Forums is not an elite anime community when it comes to knowledge of the board topic

because if I was unreasonable then that would make the thread even more garbage than it already is with alll the manhwa talk.
getting pointlessly upset and throwing around insults is something that a facebook user would do.

I was going to find the meta thread on Cred Forums, but I realized that board is largely just fine the way it is, aside from maybe the word filters.

Not to nitpick but you guys realize that the word "manwha" literally means "manga" right? They themselves call nip manga as manwha because it means the same shit - i.e. a fucking comic book.

I'm not sure how the fuck people in the western world decided to distinguish them into two separate categories but, you guys are fighting over nothing.

A correct translation would be "Korean webtoon" because yes, this shit is completely different from Japanese manga.

>polls

Let start the shitposting crusade, clean Cred Forums from gook and chink trash. They are the parasite of anime and manga

The only thing I'm against is normie /soc/ one like that Yui Santa starting cancer threads at September.
Having threads on Christmas and New Year is fine though.

Also I want a little more freedom with self moderating.
When the majority of the thread tell OP to fuck off, that means the thread is not wanted. Instead mods deletes "the shitposting" and bans everyone for reporting general.

You can say it 20,000 more times than it was already said in the past dozen meta threads. It still won't change anything. General threads are here to stay.

I do, that's why it's bad. Most threads are for battle shounen, and most of the ones that aren't are full of people with low powerlevels who mainly care about the fact that the manga in question isn't generic or whatever, as though that was a feat.

>manga mean comic from Japan
huh? huh? huh? Stop breathing, retard

If manhwa is allowed on Cred Forums, then so should western comics.

basically all 3 are the same thing amirite?

It used to be a little better, but now you just get people who download the first episode of some obscure anime, watch it before most other people early in the season, on the day of release, take screenshots so no one can reverse image search, and deliberately change the filenames so no one knows what show they are fucking talking about. These kind of people should be permanently banned.

Live action has no place on Cred Forums. You have and for that. Do you expect us to have threads for shitty Hollywood adaptations of anime and manga? Because that's what also applies here if you allow live action on Cred Forums. DJT is a force for good, but has fuckall to do with Cred Forums and belongs on or .

Despite what you seem to believe, people will not stop wanting something just because you tell them to stop. If you really want generals to stop on Cred Forums, you need to convince everyone making and posting in them that what they want is bad and wrong because you don't personally agree with it. You think banning is the answer? That's fucking laughable. I would love to see all generals banned just to see the backlash it would cause to this board. And then I would want them back because this place would be a cesspool of those same threads, just posted in higher numbers. You know, kind of how it used to be? I find it amusing how you think you have the answer when you haven't thought jack shit through other than 'REMOVE GENERALS'. You think this place would be a paradise or something if generals were a bannable offense? I think you'd better work on improving your low-quality posting; maybe that would actually benefit the board a bit.

Oh and fuck off with your "thread design" non-argument. You claim to know what posting on Cred Forums is supposed to be like when you actually don't know shit. That doesn't stop you from being an authority on it though, apparently. An imageboard doesn't have to fall into whatever pattern you seem to think it has to fall into, retard. It can take whatever shape it wants, regardless of if you want it to or not. There is no design other than what the users themselves create.

Now either explain why removing generals would solve all our problems or fuck off with the rest of you "I can't think past the basics" faggots.

Just kidding. Don't fucking bother; you don't even know what the problem is in the first place.

If threads were removed because everyone tells the OP to fuck off NTR and Naruto would be entirely removed from the board.

Don't you believe in democracy user? You don't think your voice and viewpoint is superior to anyone else's, r-right?

this maybe?

Then go some where you won't be bothered, you fucking hambeast.

Why doesn't anyone use hambeast anymore?

>if
You realize it is, right? I mean, I don't even disagree with you, but live-action adaptations are factually allowed here.

>It is a bunch of cross boarders try and change Cred Forums thread again.
Why are these not deleted on sight?

No, western comics are fundamentally different from manga in style, serialization, publishing, and themes. Chink, Jap, and Gook comics (not webtoons) all follow the same general style, serialization, publishing styles, and themes of manga.

Or the crossboarder children can just stop spouting nigger at every opportunity, screaming their Cred Forums or Cred Forums beliefs every time their pea brain deems it relevant.

Idk wtf you're goin on about but if you talk to shitty fans of a manga on Cred Forums of all hostile against fags places, its without exception always a shit manga

So what about the generals that are too /soc/?

This board is not for recommendations or for helping people get into some series. Fuck off

Way to miss my point you dumbasses.

Why the fuck are the posts asking about manwha getting deleted? I don't agree with the guy but he shouldn't be banned for expressing his opinion, especially in this thread of all places. Also, a few absolutely random posts getting deleted. No reason for this.

...

>These kind of people should be permanently banned.
Why? I don't see anything in the rules that disallows changing filenames.

Because chinese moot is here and the mods don't act out as much when he isn't gone for 5 months

And is that a bad thing?

Is that what you think you're doing when you start threads like that? You're asserting your "I hate recommendations" opinion by deliberately changing the filenames of your screenshots?

You are not a special snowflake because you watched some B-grade harem anime before someone else got around to it.

That's not what he's talking about, you triple retard.

I don't really see how being elite in knowledge of the board topic has to do with holding standards, honestly. The average user isn't particularly knowledgeable, but that doesn't mean people below a certain point can't be shat on. It also doesn't mean there aren't plenty of people worse than the average user out there.

Ban "TRIGGER" tumbrl faggots, we must take peeve back.

what point? that you want to start a useless internet fight so you nitpicked the meaning of word?

>I'm too retarded to compare the screenshot to the seasonal chart
>I can't use /wsr/ or WAIT or google or just fucking read the thread in which the image was posted or use the archives
No seriously, do redditors believe that by elitism we refer to not giving sauce instantly?

Needs an update with "this is your x for tonight".

Just ban studiofags in general.

Nice! Thanks!

Going out of your way to hide the name of the anime you are discussing and refusing to name it when asked, when it's something brand new that other people will watch eventually, just haven't seen yet, is fake elitism, and should be considered shitposting.

>making a 24/7 circlejerk general to complain about 24/7 circlejerk generals and the current state of Cred Forums

>people actually saying that elitism is a bad thing

The first three of those are blatant baiting, two of them with crossboard buzzwords, and good judgment on the mods' part. The last one I don't fucking know.

You realize that not all media player screenshots and manga pages have the series' name in them by default, right? RIGHT?

And no, we won't change the fucking filename just to sponfeed retards like you or to "hide" the name of the fucking show

It's not about being elitist. It's an extra measure to filter out retards like you.

We have a generalfag here! What general are you from? Why aren't you on a fan forum or tumblr group that caters more to you?

Seriously, what the fuck are you even rambling about? Are you that idiot from the other thread rambling about how people who don't spoonfeed should be banned? Nothing you're saying has anything to do with what said, you're just going off a completely unrelated tangent.

Not everything is about you.

...

I'll take crossboarders over sfw cunts like you.

You fat fuck.

They're the bootleg of manga, and so they're not allowed on Cred Forums

For starters why not enforce rules about image quality?

Get rid of the tumblr gifs, images pulled from facebook, reddit, and other similar places. Ban facebook filenames on sight.

You know you don't have an actual argument to address what I said and your post reflects that.
>compare to the season chart
Random screenshots don't always look like the promo art.
>/wsr/
Useless board.
>just wait
That's retarded.
>google
Did you not read my post?
>fucking read the thread
Did you not read my post?
>use the archives
To what effect? Do you even understand what I'm talking about?

I mean the apes that use ":triggered:XDXD HYPERSUPER MEMED YOU" instead of a less idiotic word like peeve

if it not comic from Japan it go to the

this

>just wait
>that's retarded

>just wait
Oh, boy, the newfags are out in full force. Lurk more, retard.

Half the posts in this thread are "blatant baiting" depending on how that's defined.

But why is Sadpanda General up? Doujinshi are by definition bootleg manga (and other formats).

>just wait
No user, WAIT

...

>installing CCCP
>Mangafox
Definitely old.

Nigger

>>just wait
>That's retarded.
Holy shit you really are this new, aren't you

Can we call out imgur filenames since imgur is associated with redditors?

Because they're comic from Japan

>>>just wait
>That's retarded.
Nigger

Where is the vote for I hate every single one of you. Any meta consensus will have people thinking it was decided by a group that isn't really Cred Forums. Just get some more mods and janitors to clean up garbage threads, cross boarders, and casuals.

...

I'm sorry about your ADHD.

Just go shit up all generals

No seriously, lurk 2 years before posting
THIS IS NOT A JOKE OR MEME, DO IT

Negro

Watching one of the 30+ watchable anime a few hours before someone else watches it does not make you "not a retard."

>Seriously, what the fuck are you even rambling about?
If you've been on Cred Forums for longer than a few months, you'll start to see threads like I'm talking about at the beginning of each new season. Sometimes, people make their threads with screenshots from the anime's PV before it has even aired so even people who watch new episodes as soon as they come out have no idea what they're talking about. That's fine and you can start a thread however you like here, but at least say what the series is when asked. It's not real elitism to know about some series just a little bit before everyone else will know about it anyway.

Those are especially bad. "Cred Forums is worse than Cred Forums, you newfag" is clear-cut shitposting, and don't even try to defend "Cred Forums is now reddit because of normies" and "weeaboos are mad."

...

Doujinshi is the fanmade of manga, fucking idiot. Chink and gook shit are just blatantly ripoff manga with only different character names

>I've never heard of 2ch

Nigger

>Literal weeaboos getting asshurt at non-japanese asian comics
I don't understand. Can someone explain this beyond "It's not made by a Japanese person"?
It's like saying bikes shouldn't be allowed on /o/. I mean technically yes but the topics are close enough to be reasonable grouped together.

I like this meme, where does it come from?

There is no "helping" anyone. You learn shit by yourself.

>Where is the vote for I hate every single one of you
You can only see it if you're trained in gorilla warfare.

Nigger.

>bump limit in the 100th thread
Stop forcing this shit.

Bootleg of manga from Japan. It's on the same level as gookshit.
>fanmade of manga
What's with the ESL faggotry? Why are you on an English board?

When the average user has a wealth of knowledge on an interest board, what is there to be elite about?

There's not allowing low quality shitposts and expecting people to have a decent level of grammar and maturity but I don't think that's really elite

Look at Those are all common thread starters and templates (along with fetish threads like something about cakes, milfs, tomboys, dfc, traps, lolis, basically generals without something in the subject field for the OP). There is no unique discussion spawned from them. I don't think that's something to be elite about

>It's like saying bikes shouldn't be allowed on /o/.
They aren't, you massive retard. They go on /n/. Thanks for proving our point.

>Cred Forums isn't a fast board l-look at Cred Forums!

I'm not talking about threads about current airing shows or anime that aired seasons ago. I'm talking about threads made about the first episode of a new anime, on the day of release. It's stupid to demand people wait when you are right there trying to have a thread about the damn thing. Wouldn't you want people who haven't seen it to go watch it? Fuck, you people are all what's wrong with this board.

So why is everyone against an /ag/? Cred Forums looks better than ever and /vg/ has on topic video game discussion.

He's probably zainichi.

Strawpoll isn't good enough to decide anything.

Why is thread still alive?

Here's a hint: WAIT refers to a website, you mong

>Those are all common thread starters and templates
Those kinds of threads are largely banned now, though, and have been for at least 2 years.

desuarchive.org/a/search/tripcode/!!WPtNxxXTYXX/
This sort of poster is why elitism is needed at times.

"Just filter it" has always been the most slippery, misleading fallacy posted to defend shit that shouldn't be here. The fact is, even if you filter generals, the cancerous newfag and offboard/offsite culture they incubate like a bacteria will spread into the other threads of the board and inescapably degrade and corrode the posting style and culture of the entire community. You can't filter every discussion on the board becoming reddit-tier garbage because posters and posting styles that should have been removed are allowed to stay behind the blinders of filters.

remember when this was actually abided by?
and if you called someone out for being a newfag, they knew it was true and what it meant and actually felt bad and went back to lurking
i miss when we were capable of bottom up community and self moderation

Oh.
Webtoon/Gookshit board when?

But why do you care that you can't find a series from an image? I mean, you wouldn't even know that such a series exists in the first place if you didn't see the image, so why get mad if you never learn the source? If the user didn't post the image you wouldn't either. This is not your recommendations board, and you can't force someone to recommend you something if they don't want to.

Confront your mother and ask her why she used to drop you when you were a baby

>you can start a thread however you want
>you must spoonfeed when you start a thread or face a ban
Holy shit you really are retarded.

Just fucking stop talking, you have made a fundamental misunderstanding and are playing the fool.

Always thought Cred Forums to be the second fastest board.

Should ban old memes like "Chaika on the front page", "Going to post this image until christmas". "Desu desu desu'.

Because any popular series will inevitably be told to fuck off to /ag/, and any discussion for a series that has a general will be forced into a cancerous general thread whether they want to associate with that faggotry or not. Generals have no place on Cred Forums. If you want to have long dedicated discussions with their own culture and where people have identities, then fuck off to Reddit or some dedicated forum.

>it's on the same level as gookshit
that's an excuse gookfags use to talk about gookshit

Wow. You are everything that's wrong with this board and you don't even realize it.

Fucking christ

Cred Forums has few legit discussion.

...

just make a new board to shovel all the korean and chinese shit into. they can have kpop threads and manwhas, even that puppet show thing.

huh? huh? huh? Are you okay, cockroach thirdworlder?

nothing you said changes the fact that you don't understand what that word means

Cred Forums should become a red board. Just saying.

We need to fucking ban LNfags who hype up shit that will inevitably suck and then have the nerve to say "just read the LN".

>If you want to have long dedicated discussions with their own culture and where people have identities

What the fuck are you talking about. I bet you're one of these retards who spams the front page with five different threads about the same fucking series.

>"fuck off to reddit" buzzword

Confirmed for shitposter, nice bait.

Bootleg of manga from Japan is still Japan therefore they should be allowed on Cred Forums

Want to see something horrifying today?

desuarchive.org/r9k/statistics/image-reposts/

This gotta be old, no way in hell /news/ is that fast and Cred Forums that slow.

It'll turn into a porn dump.

>any popular series will inevitably be told to fuck off to /ag/
i.e. "Stop making 20 fucking threads for the same topic" which fighting already makes you an idiot

>forced into a cancerous general thread
There's no difference having a general thread here or on /ag/. Go look at seasonal shit, it's all general threads except they don't have General in the title. They make a thread, they all post in it until it dies, and they move on to the next thread. They never stop talking about it. Whining about generals doesn't make them leave it just ignores the fact that they're on Cred Forums.

Fuck off, commie, we don't need your memesubs.

new thread

Modern Cred Forums is fast board when compared to old Cred Forums and when compared to vast majority of boards.
If you still think Cred Forums is medium speed you're deluded.
A manga board could be fine.

>buzzword
>y-you're just shitposting

nice try kiddo

Yeah yeah yeah just fuckoff to some gookboo forum, cockroach

BRING BACK YOTSUBA C

They have been overtaken by general discussion threads

Neato point you've made

Just shove webtoons onto Cred Forums, all idol shit onto Cred Forums or /jp/, and comics onto Cred Forums. Also have a system in place to detect nonwhites/non-english speakers and redirect them to sites that cater to their races and languages.

Ban reddit

we already have red spin offs,people use them to dump shit and are afraid to have discussions because they think they will get banned.

I've never been so insulted in all my life.

>have a system in place to detect nonwhites
What sort of fucking system would that be? And why would we ban non-whites on a fucking Chinese cartoon board, Cred Forums?

>I'm n-not shitposting

But you are, kid.

Add a report function for "poor use of English".

>b-but muh board culture
You have never been on those boards, those generals are the least cancerous Cred Forums has right now.

>shitpost thread
>one liner with waifufagging pic

So posting a different kind of shitpost is bad now? This is why we don't need assblasted neckbeard as local mods. Global mods can use common sense instead.

Fucking kill yourself, parasite

>missquoting
>not knowing who you're fighting with anymore

you just wanted a useless internet fighr didn't you?

>if I don't like your choice of waifu, that means it's OK for me to spam whatever I want in your thread
We don't do this on Cred Forums anymore.

tyranny of the majority

Here you go mod/jan have fun

You do know what a general is, right?

Not him, but that was one guy who would go into every thread on any of the three battle harems and shitpost by dumping Stella images and starting arguments with his bad English, for months on end. It was absolutely banworthy.

that's not how you use that meme you fucking retard, you ruined it

Go to the new thread.

Elitism is for keeping the unintelligent out with no fucking brain at all that can't even be bothered to lurk or google for recommendations/sauce(feel free to add to this).
Now that we are completely fucking straight on this (because somehow we aren't), once you remove these 2 bit mouth breathers we are able to focus just a little bit more on discussion,OC creation, etc. with the community that at least has a quarter of a fucking brain.
It is literally about quality control at the lowest level (a whole shitload if this is getting through currently.)
Being a fucking prick is pointless when you have a good discussion going.
holykafuckingmolydesu excuse my shitty hastily written rant

>detect nonwhites
>redirect them to sites that cater to their races
I want you to think carefully about what the topic of this board is.

>meme

You really are retarded.

Holy shit, dont act like you have unanimous board agreement and all further discussion is over, you faggot. While I agree with most of these, and that LN discussion should be allowed, Manwa and Manhua don't fucking belong here, this board should be for non-vidya Japanese weeb culture, not everything East Asia shits out general.

We need to ban all tripcunts. Kill yourself, attention whore.

Is that seriously the best you have? that's sad kid.

I am happy with things the way they are and therefore feel no need to monitor these threads. Please take feedback with a grain of salt.

autism

...

Checked

Checked

>It was absolutely banworthy.

But so should these shitty waifu spam thread.

If you really want to make a serious image sharing thread then make it look like one. Not invite to shitposting by talking like a retard in the OP.

>when u attempt to stop the shitposting but get more shitposting by getting trips
chekt

Cred Forums is meant for a high degree of inflammatory content. I'm not saying this in an 'epicc Cred Forums' way but anonymous culture invites to have people shit on one another with extreme prejudice.

If you want a mild environment for regulated sharing then you should go on those places with permanent threads and accounts where rules are easily enforced and people have a reputation to maintain.

HIRO DON'T LISTEN TO THIS POLL.
Votes on strawpoll can be easily faked using proxy.

Kill yourself, kid.

Remember, shitposting and generals are the results of overmoderation.
Increasing the level of moderation even further is not a solution to stopping them, it'll smother the board for good.

Go fuck yourself

explain what you mean by that moeshit

why? and why do you think I'm a kid? do you really think that or are you just copying me like an average 12 year old would do when they're out of insults?