Is that valid criticism

Kevin Nguyen
Kevin Nguyen

I hate it because it is popular

is that valid criticism

Other urls found in this thread:

youtu.be/FlzZhGr8G9w?t=33s

Isaac Edwards
Isaac Edwards

Seeing Re:zero threads everyday makes me hate it even more so yeah

Christian Kelly
Christian Kelly

yes

Oliver Gray
Oliver Gray

Depends on the context of the criticism.

Blake Roberts
Blake Roberts

If it's re:0, then yes.

Andrew Long
Andrew Long

Guys, it's over. Let's just forget about it and stop triggering my PTSD

Nathan Gray
Nathan Gray

It's the one reason I refuse to watch One Punch Man.

Really glad I steered clear of Matsu threads when that was running. If I had seen the rabid fandom in action I would have never watched a pretty great show.

/blog

Carson Rivera
Carson Rivera

I would say it's akin to saying something is overrated. It's not a valid criticism of the work in question by itself.

Isaac Lewis
Isaac Lewis

No, unless you're a teenage hipster.

Lucas Cook
Lucas Cook

Liking only popular anime is born from fear of diversity. Marks my words, you fools.

Owen Ramirez
Owen Ramirez

If the great popularity causes harassment, then yes

Jackson Wilson
Jackson Wilson

The reason I sometimes get turned off of popular anime is all the people sperging about it. It sometimes gets to the point where I'm tired of hearing about it and it makes me not want to watch it, even if it interested me originally.

Hudson Myers
Hudson Myers

There is no such thing as valid or invalid criticism. Or rather, you personally decide whether criticism is valid or invalid, and that's different for every person.

Jordan Roberts
Jordan Roberts

Yes now fuck off.

Benjamin Hughes
Benjamin Hughes

No the logic is

I hate the fanbase ergo I don't like dicussing it or seeing pictures of it regardless of its quality thus reducing my overall enjoyment of the media.

It's a negative externality caused by shitty plebs, like being in a bar and some stinky crazy hobo starts yelling about Xenu.

Landon Lee
Landon Lee

No, that's petty contrarian behaviour. View something not for its fanbase or how well known it is but on its own merits

It's like when someone says "Cowboy Bebop is over rated" it's highly venerated for good reason if someone hates it for that reason they're a filthy hipster.

youtu.be/FlzZhGr8G9w?t=33s

Mason Baker
Mason Baker

No, that's barely an argument.

William Ward
William Ward

People can like or hate whatever they want, but it invalidates future opinions because they have shown they let other people decide what they like and hate.

Adrian Lee
Adrian Lee

Yea, this is me.

Ethan Ramirez
Ethan Ramirez

I like what you wrote.

Cooper Sanders
Cooper Sanders

That's not a criticism but it's a valid reason to not like something

Nolan Gomez
Nolan Gomez

I donno man. There are certain shows that I just can't see how they're popular. Like SAO for instance, the first bit and beginning actually drew me in and I thought the internet was just hating it because it was popular like your saying OP. then it got a little meh when the two main characters got married. but then the fairies shit happened. Dear lord it took me a bottle of southern comfort and dedication to get through those final terrible episodes. everything that made it interesting at first was gone and it was just bad.

I haven't even attempted season 2.

Ethan White
Ethan White

What makes Toradora! so good?

Joshua Rivera
Joshua Rivera

good romance

Gabriel Watson
Gabriel Watson

It's more irritation for constantly seeing praise of something you think isn't praiseworthy, so basically "stop liking what I don't like".

Grayson Lopez
Grayson Lopez

I'd say not because it is popular, but because of the rabid followers that make it popular and try to force it on you. Not watching the show and/or developing hate for it would be the consequence of that.

Aiden Parker
Aiden Parker

If you're on Cred Forums

Caleb Jones
Caleb Jones

I do agree with that assertion. Fortunately, there is a way to get rid of such threads by simply hiding them.

It really helps with the nerves if those kind of threads are out of sight.

Ethan Gonzalez
Ethan Gonzalez

Are you implying that rightfully calling on the shit taste of faggots to make them realize their poor choices is somehow not valid?

Where do you think you are?

Logan Torres
Logan Torres

It's valid if you want it to be. But your valid isn't my valid, or anyone else's valid.

Levi Jackson
Levi Jackson

The only ones that say this are the people that do not actually enjoy watching anime and only enjoy discussing anime. Therefore, if they dislike the following of an anime that they would have to discuss it with, they will not watch it.

Jonathan Sanders
Jonathan Sanders

/thread

Noah Miller
Noah Miller

Nobody actually says that. It's more like
I don't like this series and it's popularity has made it's flaws increasingly obvious to me due to overexposure and unwarranted praise

The real illogical bullshit is the fans who call everyone who dislikes something contrarian and accuses them of hating it for being popular.

Samuel Hernandez
Samuel Hernandez

Well If I can discuss it here then my standards go way down, even bad anime can be fun to discuss, and only the rare good anime is fun to watch.

Christian Adams
Christian Adams

only on Cred Forums

Austin Murphy
Austin Murphy

lurk more kid, only idiots use fallacies.

Elijah Jones
Elijah Jones

Popularity is a fair way to gauge whether or not something is probably shit or not.

Oliver Jackson
Oliver Jackson

It isn't for people with more than 70 IQ, in Cred Forums it is.

Jose Campbell
Jose Campbell

Well written characters with actual relationship building and development.

Sebastian Smith
Sebastian Smith

the characters.