Out of pic related, who's best protag?

you realize these are cartoons yeah senpai?

Minato

but Margaret is best Velvet Room assistant

That depends
Door kun is cool but his harem sucks
Joker kun is cool and his harem is good filled with milfs
FeMC, can't self insert, not interested
And finally Yu kun, or sensei. Decent harem

...

>Minato's harem sucks
>but Yu's is decent

holy Christ loving fuck, this shit taste

Maya.

>Door kun is cool but his harem sucks
>Yu kun, or sensei. Decent harem
Fucking idiot.
>FeMC, can't self insert, not interested
Fucking faggot.

>Mitsuru fags

It has less to do with the P3 cast and more with the fact that P4's is probably the worst one in the series.

Yukari is my favorite.

But Mitsuru is still better than any of the dumpster whores in P4.

How?
You got slutty idol
Tomboy bro girl
Trap detective
Pure inn owner daughter
Little junior blushing musician
Bitch blondie, for the femdom fags
Theatre whore
And who else???
Oh little loli sister

Even worse.

>lightskin dudes battling
>not hugging it out with young drake softly playing over the aux

Best girls.
Any questions?

>dual loli that can fusion to become ultimate loli

Joker-kun all the way.

>Trap detective
Annoying as fuck and heralded as "really smart" despite the fact that she just says obvious shit that non-oblivious people can easily discern.

>Tomboy bro girl
Literally the worst girl in the entire franchise. TRIAL OF THE DRAGEN LMAO :^)

>Pure inn owner daughter
Autistic bitch with zero character. I can get liking her only if you really like pantyhose.

Everyone else is irrelevant, Rise is all right but that's only one fucking person.

>How?
Because you just described every facet of their personalities in that post.

Makoto and yukari? You're joking??????

>only p3 and onwards

Nice cucking.

Replace Yukari with anyone and I'd be inclined to agree.

>Minato
>gets killed off and dies a virgin
>Yu
>survives and occasionally visits his friends doing fun shit without having to worry about shit
>P5MC
>gets cucked multiple times by older men and Yakuza and gets shot like a bitch in the bad ending

P1 and P2 are are garbage.

Should I just play the translated version of the ps1 game of Eternal Punishment or should I wait for the fan translation?

>drug addicted yakuza cumdump
>not neet
Even with inevitable memes, she's alright.

4/5 ain't bad

Good job

You've fallen for the cuck memes.

Do i have to post the webm?

>worst P1 P3 and P4 girls

>cucking your best friend

asshole

>P5
She's a good choice but best choice is goth doc.

Unless it shows one of the girls being penetrated, no, because it doesn't mean shit.

Dude the game has been recorded, that shit is out of context.
Only one that's true is cumdump for failing deadline and fiancé.
Dude you can fuck every SL girl. And they're cakes.

I like the non-canon femMC the best. Namely because it was refreshing to have a persona MC that wasn't some dull-ass pretty boy for a change, and because naginatas are rad.
Plus she gets to slap hoes in not one, but two of her SL, which was satisfying.

That one out of context webm with Anne getting into the car?
I played the game buddy it's not what it seems.

Yeah. Why is Rise disguised as Yukiko?

>judging who's the better mc out of the haremshit around him

kek best JRPG my ass with your terrible written characters

But I am not. I am judging her out of liking her design and finding a female MC enjoyable. I actually have no interest in the harem bits of Persona, and it's one of the reasons I dropped 4 and 5 halfway through once I noticed the plot wasn't much to give a care about and the characters weren't awfully likeable.

Not to say P3 is better written, but its setting appealed more to me than the next two did as it remained with a semblance of seriety similar to 2 still and it had only just begun with the whole dating simulator shenanigans. Which back then were in fact surprisingly challenging, at least in the original P3 anyways, and making a schedule for the MC to follow in order to not screw up any SL was like... harder than some bosses oddly.
Not that it was what I signed up for.

>Bitch blondie, for the femdom fags
Did you even do her social link? She defrosts quickly, so there's no chance of femdom happening. She's also best girl, though I wouldn't necessarily want to date her.

Anne, Makoto, and goth doc are the only ones that really interest me in 5, and I'm not going to take Ryuji's girl, so that's only two choices for me. Does goth doc have an annoying personality or anything?

>Only one that's true is cumdump for failing deadline and fiancé.
Wait so she actually gets turned into a prostitute for Yakuza if you fuck up.
No pressure or anything.

at least you got yukiko right
1/3 isn't that bad

Can you still get Elizabeth if you play as FeMC?

>Goth doc have an annoying personality.
Not that I'm aware of. Everybody says she's really sweet.

Yep.

>i am everyone in this thread

NEET also kills herself if you fail.

yes

Wonderful. Now if only I could still fug the Mitsuru, I'd have a reason to play P3P

FeMC

Well, yes. We are one person. Not take my hand out of our dick.

You can still have a "senpaiii" relationship with her and bath together (often), and then go fuck Elizabeth which you still can.
So there's that.

Christ.
How badly can Potter fuck up in this?

>take my hand out of our dick.

they are pretty cute together

I like this one more

This one, and FeMc plus Margaret is best attendant.

>not being FemMC
>not fucking the dog, the child and the druggie while Akihiko thinks you are his perfect waifu

user pls

Yeah.
Police come saying they found some chick drugged off her mind where they sell that stuff, but mentions your name and PT.
Then framing device of interrogation takes place, detective says that the drugs the police made you take must be fucking up your mind still, leaves and Goro shoots you in the head.
Maybe phantom has these cuck fantasies.

I like five the best from what I've seen. He seems like an actual person instead of a self insert plot device

Persona didn't start at 3 you know.

Yes it did.
The difference between 2 and 3 are massive.

Lol okay

Maya and Tatsuya have preset personalities so they don't exactly land on the same level as the rest.

And the original Persona MC is as flat as a character can get and his design is terrible altogether so who wants to ever discuss him.

Wow.

What's wrong with his design? He's quite handsome?

Wait, the two lolis fuse?

>implying that's not wishful fanart looks
>implying he doesn't actually look like Ellen Degeneres about to rape you through the screen

FeMC, all other choices are wrong

All other timelines are wrong

Also Tatsuya, but he did everything wrong

Fixed it.

>cares about "canon"
>removes FemMC but doesn't add any of the previous MCs that actually made the settings exist to begin with