>band is like "to hell with it, if we're going to end this, we're going to make it right" >features Ringo's best song and two of George's finest tracks >includes the most iconic album cover ever >contains the true masterpiece that is the side b medley >has mccartney's most powerful vocal performance >has a song with all four singing at the same time (think it's the only song where they done it) >it reprises a previous track in a very melancholic way bringing a tear to the eye and it's probably the most touching moment in rock history >last song is called 'the end' which has absolutely amazing solo guitars and Ringo's only drum solo in his whole career >concludes with a phrase which transmites the same message this amazing band has been giving since the very first day it started: love
Why isn't it the best album of all time again?
Thomas Nelson
Rubber Soul had better songs
Aside from that, partly because classical music has been recorded
Jason Phillips
>Why isn't it the best album of all time again?
Pet Sounds exists.
Brayden Fisher
when are people gonna get over this bland mundane overrated literal original dadrock?
Parker Richardson
because better albums exist
David Jackson
You're all wrong.
Asher Morales
I don't think it's the best album of all time, but I don't fault you for thinking that.
It's definitely the best thing the Beatles put out though.
Adrian Mitchell
>buzzwords: the post
Blake Lopez
shut up, nerd
Asher Cox
>Why isn't it the best album of all time again? not as ~innovative~
Rubber Soul better and probably a better contender for best rock album
Leo Roberts
I'm glad someone shares the same opinion as me for carry that weight
Luis Ramirez
anyone who feels emotional resonance for the medley (something every member but paul felt was contrived and shitty) is literally retarded
it's a pop band, getting emotional over that is like getting emotional over the ending of a one direction album
Brandon Murphy
Lots of hipster faggots in this thread
This album is one of the greatest albums of all time
Henry Martin
>"look at me, I'm so above this" >"lol the fact that this means anything to you means you're literally retarded"
Thomas Gomez
ooh, strawmanning
looks like i struck a nerve
i guess if your feelings are tickled by some cheesy forced shit like paul's gay little medley at the end, then they're bound to be tickled by some stranger on the internet making fun of you for being a huge faggot
Kevin Parker
...
Josiah Garcia
erm
that's not strawmanning
Aiden Harris
quote where i said i was above anything
Lincoln Williams
>comparing the beatles to one direction
ooh, edgy. Just discovered Cred Forums? The essentials are so great aren't they, there's so much more to music than the boring dadrock everyone loves!
Ian Rodriguez
that is not what strawmanning is. strawmanning implies an argument has been made - it hasn't
Wyatt Anderson
You need an argument between two points to strawman buddy
Adam Ross
they aren't comparable to 1d except for the medley, it's literally a fan pleasing contrived shitpost in musical form that paul concocted that nobody else really cared about
ringo literally had to be coaxed into doing a solo, he didn't even want to do it
the definition of manufactured, designed to make the listener "feel" something and you literally fell for it almost 50 years later, well done
Logan Cook
Why, because critics told you so?
Parker Edwards
hey scruffles
Jacob Murphy
I'll never understand why people like the beatles so much some of the most bland pop music ever todd rundgren made way better music
Kayden Barnes
>it's a pop band, getting emotional over that is like getting emotional over the ending of a one direction album
Jack White
>weezer reaction img
wow what a shocker
Joshua Sullivan
The fact that so many books still name the Beatles as "the greatest or most significant or most influential" rock band ever only tells you how far rock music still is from becoming a serious art. Jazz critics have long recognized that the greatest jazz musicians of all times are Duke Ellington and John Coltrane, who were not the most famous or richest or best sellers of their times, let alone of all times. Classical critics rank the highly controversial Beethoven over classical musicians who were highly popular in courts around Europe. Rock critics are still blinded by commercial success. The Beatles sold more than anyone else (not true, by the way), therefore they must have been the greatest. Jazz critics grow up listening to a lot of jazz music of the past, classical critics grow up listening to a lot of classical music of the past. Rock critics are often totally ignorant of the rock music of the past, they barely know the best sellers. No wonder they will think that the Beatles did anything worthy of being saved.
Jose Rodriguez
You must be new here Just because it's Cred Forums it doesn't mean you have to hate popular music, especially the Beatles
Logan Gray
quote me where i said i hate the beatles
Owen Morris
It's only comparable to Revolver and Pet Sounds if we're talking about 60s pop albums. Still, I find it amazing that they were able to put out such a masterpiece after the band had fallen apart.
Can you guys recommend some records as good as those three? Odessey And Oracle is pretty damn fine too.
Michael Gray
...
Dylan Ramirez
this tbf
Elijah Wood
this is better, yes you are right
Ayden Perez
lads lets make more songs about sea animals
Jack Mitchell
>it was made with the intention of making listeners feel emotional >it succeeds, therefore is bad wtf?
Asher Smith
>Beatles '65 >Released in December 1964
bravo
Justin Peterson
Literally name one album
Tyler Lopez
This thread is one big meme right? Please tell me no one listens to this dad rock shit
Jason Gomez
Honestly the Beatles are now granddad rock
If someone was someone was 18 when the Beatles released their first album they would be 71 years old now
Levi Powell
John>Paul>>>>>Ringo>George
James Ross
time to grow up kid
Isaiah Davis
I Want You (She's So Heavy) is the best thing John ever did, it's so great.
Ryder Clark
George > John > Paul > Ringo
Colton Cooper
weezer is the worst part of mu core
worse than captain beefheart
Chase Myers
>Honestly the Beatles are now granddad rock Maybe if you hang out with exclusively teenagers