>Fell out with his writing partner and friend >Fell out with his best mate and the guy who made him laugh the most >All of his recent projects have bombed or been panned by critics and public or at least fallen into mediocrity territory >In order to stay relevant, he had to desperately resurrect his most famous character for a movie that also bombed >He now occupies his time doing this youtube.com/watch?v=zem24JqxFjs
He's filthy fucking rich. I think he still craves the fame but it really doesnt matter at this point.
I just want them 3 to give us a few more seasons of podcasts for the good old times.
If Ricky's desperation leads to that, im all for it.
Juan Taylor
Was the Brent movie really that bad?
Jace Gomez
You have to question whether he was funny at all and whether the Office was just a uniquely shot show that appealed to normies who worked in boring offices.
It wasn't very brilliant or anything and nothing he did before or after was that great.
Juan Carter
YA 'AVIN A LAUGH?!
Samuel Murphy
Was just about to post this.
I was around when Gervais was on the 11 o clock show way back in teh 90s and I called it even THEN - he isn't that good. Even then he was hot or miss and this was before he had even an ounce of self-deprecation. When The Office aired I called it again saying that I was skeptical he had the talent and would be curious to see how he fared without Merchant.
Have a look at that youtube video with himself, Seinfield, Chris Rock and Louis CK. They all clearly had done the stand up circuit for YEARS honing and refining the craft and having the humility to know when stuff simply didn't work. Gervais doesn't have that ability at all and it's some of the most painful viewing as he tries to join in constantly and they are just being as polite as they can be when its clear he has no idea what he's talking about.
Ethan Roberts
He's fallen out with Steve and Karl?
Any evidence, or are we making assumptions based on lack of working together?
Owen Bennett
He can do a show with Opie now.
Charles Hall
>Fell out with his writing partner and friend >Fell out with his best mate and the guy who made him laugh the most
What happened? I haven't been following shit.
Wyatt King
He doing a new stand up soon, maybe hes been spending time writing it or something.
Hes never been THAT relevant anyway and the only thing people will remember will be the office and an idiot abroad
Isaiah Ramirez
That poor, poor man. He has nothing to live for, other than the hundreds of millions of dollars and hundreds of thousands of adoring fans. Glad I'm not that guy.
Christian Roberts
Extras was pretty good. That bit with Patrick Stewart may be the funniest thing he's ever done.
Joshua Cruz
the way he harasses the cat is like how he harasses his "friends", glad it scratched him tbqh
Kevin Bailey
Yeah i think Extras is his magnum dong and has rewatch value. The office was unique in it's time and good the first time you watch it, but ive never felt the urge to rewatch. I did like the stand up shows he did too actually. That's about it. The xfm stuff doesn't count because its all spontaneous and only funny because of Karl.
Aiden Edwards
wish he would get steve and karl back and just do podcasts until they die. i miss them.
Adrian Smith
Word has it he has an enormous schlong. As in, "why did you choose comedy instead of fucking extremely-loose bimbos with your freakishly-large schlong?" schlong.
Word also has it that he fell out with Stephen Merchant, because Stephen's girlfriend Hayley Atwell wanted to see Ricky's enormous schlong, and ended up letting him fuck her.
Easton Flores
i'm glad this guy's self-absorbed abrasiveness and egotism has finally caught up with him
though this is Cred Forums so your post is probably completely wrong
Gavin Turner
Agreed. Extras is undeniably great.
Derek is shit apart from a select few scenes, mostly poop humor and that outtake of Kev pretend-fucking the fatty in their trailer.
Asher Ross
You should rewatch The Office. I did these past few weeks and it still is absolutely brilliant
Levi Rogers
Has Ricky ever done anything good without Stephen? The Office, Extras, An Idiot Abroad, Life's Too Short and Cemetery Junction were all with Stephen.
Nicholas Miller
>>Fell out with his writing partner and friend >>Fell out with his best mate and the guy who made him laugh the most
I don't think this is true user
Alexander Turner
Stephen is less funny than Ricky on his own.
Noah Torres
Well has Stephen ever done anything good on his own?
That US sitcom is fucking shit.
Colton Perez
Hello Ladies was great.
Christopher Rogers
I don't disagree, but I think it might be a situation where neither can do it all by themselves, but they're really good together.
Brody Myers
Show me proof that they're still talking to each other.
Jayden Perez
it is a rerun of his stand up, and the stand up is shit
Parker Baker
show me proof they aren't
Christian Long
>>Fell out with his writing partner and friend >>Fell out with his best mate and the guy who made him laugh the most fell out with steve and karl? what? explain this shit.
Juan Wright
As much as they made better comedy as a duo, Stephen's prob doing a lot better away from him
Ricky, from all I've seen of him, is one of those friends who always talks over you and slows down your development as a person
I say that as someone who likes his work
Samuel Campbell
>only funny because of Karl Whilst I do find Karl very funny, for me some of the funniest parts of the XFM shows are Ricky and Steve randomly riffing off each other in funny little exchanges. Steve's anecdotes are always a treat too.
Carson Allen
came here to post this
Chase Cook
Why did he fall out with merchant anyway?
Asher Morgan
>>Fell out with his writing partner and friend >>Fell out with his best mate and the guy who made him laugh the most Give source faggot.
Owen Johnson
fucking answer us faggot
Parker James
i cant believe this guy is so washed up he has an active youtube channel with dozens of videos of him alone in his apartment getting bitten by a cat that hates his guts. is... is he gonna be ok? where are his friends? family? why is his apartment so lonely? why does his cat maul him? why does he frequently make and upload these videos?
Samuel Turner
It's not true. They are just working on separate projects.
Liam Diaz
>Have a look at that youtube video with himself, Seinfield, Chris Rock and Louis CK. They all clearly had done the stand up circuit for YEARS honing and refining the craft and having the humility to know when stuff simply didn't work. Gervais doesn't have that ability at all and it's some of the most painful viewing as he tries to join in constantly and they are just being as polite as they can be when its clear he has no idea what he's talking about.
THIS, I like the bloke but he's a fucking fish out of water in this video, the worse part is he organised it and thought he was on par with these comedic greats
That dude has been telling the same jokes for 10 years.
What, that sounds awful.
Ryan Gonzalez
This makes me sad. He just wanted to be one of the boys but couldn't make it. Now he gets bitten by cats for 50 views on youtube.
Brandon Allen
desu, Seinfeld is the least funny guy in that room
Ethan Reed
Kinda just seems like he is picking their comedy brains, he isn't trying to keep up. How else can you get 3 comedy greats in a room and just talk with them for an hour?
Jace Cook
Have you seen his Garry Shandling interview? It's a goldmine of IRL cringe.
watching an episode took me an hour on average because I had to hit pause and walk off the cringe every other scene
wathign an ep took me an hour
Christopher Rogers
a face made for bashing in with a shovel
Nathan Edwards
Nothing has been said in public about their relationship apart from Steve saying they are now just doing their own thing and taking a break (youtube.com/watch?v=0-kulDq2-3s)
I think after the failure of Life's Too Short and Cemetary Junction, compared to Extras and The Office, they decided their partnership wasnt working as well as it used to so they are on hiatus.
Right now I am listening to the xfm shows again and it's clear to me that Ricky and Karl had a special relationship and Steve was sort of left out. Ricky also had a special relationship with celebrities like Jonathan Ross and left Steve out of that. Ricky is just too self absorbed
Julian Johnson
this show was trash. because i like the guy i gave it time and watched alot of it. its prety shit. so retarded its not funny alot of the time.
Ian Harris
atheism doesnt make you bitter mate, thats rather ignorant
source on all the fall outs?
Christopher Allen
How is Jonathan Ross? All right?
Ian Cox
hmmmm
Isaac Richardson
It's pretty clear he's more a mediator between all of them and only joking around a little bit compared to the others. I mean if you're gonna criticize someone at least make sure it's legit.
Jeremiah Brooks
Good I hate that smarmy faggot
Jaxson Young
IS 'E 'AVIN' A LAUGH?
Jack Price
There were a few times when they kind of just stared at him, like when he tried to bring it back to sitting on a cock cause I'm gay. Or Chris Rock being pretty cold blooded about The Office.
The running joke of Sitting on a cock cause I'm gay was 10/10 though
John Perez
This was pretty upsetting to watch because of how they treat Ricky. I'm not really a big Ricky fan but jesus christ, Chris Rock clearly has no respect for Gervais and it's so obvious that it's painful. Ricky brings up plenty of valid points and Rock and Seinfeld just stomp all over him.
Jason Ramirez
>4mil views on Learning English ft Karl Part 1 >never does a Part 2
?
Xavier Lewis
Presumably because Karl wised up - and became fed up - with his self-absorbed parasitic horseshit a la Robin Ince et al > pic related; Me In Honey
Kayden Adams
It's fun seeing them all trying to wrap their heads around Seinfeld's massive success without every joke needing the word "fuck" though. Would be interesting to see Seinfeld do a nigger bit.
Jonathan Mitchell
New to atheism are you? went through 10 years of Atheism and if you have more than one brain cell you'll begin to realise that Nihilism is the only logical ism that can come from it. Nihilism is shitty on you and everyone around you. Decided to become a Druid 5 years ago and life has never been better.
Liam Lopez
It's pretty much that they haven't worked together on anything for a while and their separate work was shit (you think Gervais would want to after Derek's failure) and there's no indication they even "might"
Karl doesn't want to do more TV so it's unlikely we'll ever get the three back together and anything though and without Karl, Merchant/Gervias really aren't that funny.
Gabriel White
>comedy greats They're all shit
John Scott
steve is hosting the crystal maze: charity special
Don't treat atheism as a religion and you'll be fine
Jackson Kelly
They had one interesting TV show idea with Karl and did it in the worst fucking way possible.
An Idiot Abroad could have been great if they slowed it down and dedicated more time to each country.
Henry Price
>Don't treat a religion as a religion!
oy m8
Joseph Ramirez
me in the middle
Angel Long
>analyzing someone this hard based purely on your own dislike
Come on son.
Xavier Green
Why do you question that, especially since you don't think it was 'very brilliant or anything'?
The Office is an amazing show for way more than how it was shot. Its thematically airtight in the way it was designed around the office environment. If anything, The Office was too brilliant since Ricky has only gone downhill since then.
Ayden Martin
extras was good
Henry Butler
It replicated the same character arc (for Gervais) of self realisation, and attrition, that The Office employed much more effectively The stunt casting was a limited gimmick which decreases in relevance as time ticks forwards
Blake Reed
I thought Extras was really funny, but the Invention of Lying was so shitty that I never bothered with Ricky after that.
Isaac Brooks
He was only good when working with Steve.
Jonathan Adams
Ricky's tv shows: amazing to mediocre Ricky's films: all shit
Kayden Mitchell
Cemetery Junction was alright
Eli Taylor
Links to Steve Merchant and Karl Pilkington disassociating themselves with Ricky?
Connor Bennett
No, Jerry Seinfeld is by far the weak link here. Also, Chris Rock is hardly sacrosanct. It's fucking Chris Rock.
Josiah Brooks
People might give a fuck about your opinion if you mastered basic punctuation and spelling.
Jaxson Taylor
You can really sense Garry Shandling's disdain for that lowly goyim
Josiah Gray
>not watching things in hourly five minute instalments
Jack Martin
I'm glad. I can't stand the cunt.
Nathan Nguyen
Is he wearing a bald cap or did he legitimately shave his head for a one-off charity special?
Bentley Ortiz
>multi millionaire comedian and actor >now spends his days tweeting about atheism and posting cat videos on youtube that struggle to get a couple hundred views
Jesus Christ I hope these Facebook videos get more viewers when he streams live because that is just tragic.
Levi Harris
I am sure his head was already shaved for his role in wolverine 3, there is a video of him shaving it off on his instagram
Chase James
Ricky plz..
William Barnes
He was wearing a cap on Norm's show, I think to hide the balding Look back at his appearance on the ITV breakfast show fairly recently; there was some crafty combing going on to disguise his rapidly receding hairline
Elijah Jones
The fact that still talk about each other but they don't talk about him unless asked.
Kayden Martinez
Is Steve the first celebrity to re-JUST himself?
Luke Martin
The change from his youth is astounding.
Henry James
No, ive never believed in god and i'm perfectly happy
Noah Baker
He's teetered on the precipice of JUST since birth >that anecdote where Lucy Davis pushes his glasses up and they stick against his boggly eyes
Jonathan Walker
I'm a rogue-wizard multiclass and i'm doing ok
Jacob Taylor
>"Not religious" is a religion Not this shit again m8
Brody Anderson
Nah, that guy has it right. I used to be a paladin but I switched to full time cleric mode and life's never been better.
Only someone retarded enough to think Gervais was some kind of great thinker of our times would be retarded enough to actually get a tattoo of him next to Dawkins
Kayden Green
>Only someone retarded enough would be retarded enough
oh user..
Robert Ramirez
why?
Sebastian Wright
Thou shalt not have gods before me
Easton Young
I know what I typed faggot and I stand by it.
Ayden King
>you have ten seconds to think of TWO FAMOUS ATHEISTS >dawkins, richard dawkins >...and? >argh i dunno erm >five seconds left >ARGH errr RICKY GERVAIS! >that's two! you did it! ready for the tattoo? >sure am! >*one massive tattoo later* >now let's look at the famous atheists you COULD'VE gone with...
Jacob Bennett
I wonder about this sometimes, I think he has the ability to make amazing things but hollywood has kind of ruined him. The office was a great show. It may not seem like it now but that would be because of how many other shows copied it. There are so many things that are in the office that modern comedies copy it's just mundane now. Obviously they perfected and popularized the mockumentary style but also the cringe humor really started with the office. Even if you don't like the office you have to give credit where it's due
Aaron Davis
why do people get other peoples faces tattooed on themselves? kids, wife, yeah i can sorta understand. but famous strangers? fuck, its so weird.
Nolan White
Stephen Merchant is quite obviously the writing talent
Jeremiah Carter
People being weird with their pets makes me reconsider my anti-natalism. I love my doggo but if I start treating it like a child like this faggot does with his cat, I hope I die in my sleep soon after.
Blake Powell
This was pure cringe kino but I can't believe it got commissioned in the US
Cameron Nguyen
Which is better UK Office or USA version? And why do americunts need to remake a series entirely not to suffer hearing brit accents?
Sebastian Price
I prefer hedonism tbhfam
Jaxon Harris
US version, and there are like 15 different versions of The Office made in different countries, take the broomstick out of your ass biatch
Jacob Wright
Idiot Abroad was great until they brought in the fucking midget. God, what an insufferable ass.
David Price
REEE that little faggot was so annoying. Was offended by everything, a party pooper, etc
Sebastian Butler
US Version is dreadful. UK version is the true version
Adam Williams
Ruined the entire thing. Not even a based midget like Dinklage just a moaning faggot.
Liam Cruz
if only he'd write that well for his solo Comedy, jesus
Ryan Russell
He was such a snidey little brat.
Christian Nguyen
Atheism does make you extremely bitter. If you're some teenage atheist you're in for a terrible ride.
Jayden Miller
Thanks senpai that clears it up.
Isaiah Sullivan
>their greatest achievement was running a literally what radio show for a literally who radio station during the dead hours of a Saturday
I'd be bitter too.
Kevin Diaz
Yea but he probably went in expecting to talk business and instead got Chris Rock trying his damnedest to be insightful and the wonder twins in the corner cackling at dick jokes.
Jace Cruz
Atheism frees you from constant spiritual crises as well as giving you a good bit of spare time that you can use for the better.
Jaxon Hill
Why are religiousfags always so insecure about their shit?
Xavier Robinson
US version if you want a bunch of people shouting. UK version if you want decent humour.
Ryan Baker
>pretending to know whether there's a god or not
"The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wiser people so full of doubts." - Bertrand Russell
Jose Price
Why does Atheism give you spare time?
Nathan Reyes
>atheism frees you from constant spiritual crises No it doesn't. It can, but so can theism.
Connor Lewis
This post could be applied to anything that is found in both the UK and the USA.
Josiah Perez
Theism is the main cause of it, you can't possibly avoid it unless you're a brainwashed fanatic and very sheltered, and even then it's always behind the corner.
Dylan Allen
Spare time on Sundays.
Leo Torres
This is what atheism does to people.
Zachary Hall
you're the one replying
Easton Bell
lol you got any more webms like that? it looks like some people are taking that whole fighting thing more seriously than others
Thomas Morgan
Who's Line is it Anyway is the anomaly for me at least
Ryan Hernandez
I also want more HEMA webms from . Makes me want to go play Chivalry again.
John Barnes
this is maximum autism
Blake Bennett
haha lol.
Anthony Cox
I always thought Merchant was a tool and a a hack
Lincoln Miller
Not battle of nations fighting, but still has swords.
Adrian Diaz
Iain Lee?
Ayden Foster
>atheism doesnt make you bitter mate, thats rather ignorant
I didn't lol, but I did grin. It certainly makes most people bitter. Plus, bitter people tend to become atheists. Either way, you end up with a shitload of bitter atheism. And they try to fool themselves into thinking they aren't miserable by trying to make everyone else as miserable as they are.
Justin Howard
>and if you have more than one brain cell you'll begin to realise that Nihilism is the only logical ism that can come from it. Nihilism is shitty on you and everyone around you. True, but Nihilism might not be the dead end that we fear it is. I see two possible ways out.
1. Absurdism.
2. Since you can never be 100% that life has no purpose of meaning, there BECOMES meaning: to search for it. Think about it- half of the existential angst that comes from nihilism is that nothing you do, no choice you make, is logical. Therefore, everything you do or don't do is illogical. However, if your life goal is to SEARCH for a point, then your actions ARE logical.
Jack Torres
I wouldn't say he's completely talentless, but I would wholeheartedly agree he's a one hit wonder that subsequently got propped up by surrounding himself with much more talented people. And yeah, that video is really cool as a whole but Ricky does look just pathetic by comparison. When Seinfeld and Louie start debating about the merits of reusing material versus always coming up with new stuff they make great cases for either side and you can tell they approach it as craftsmen who disagree but respect one another, then Gervais chimes in and Seinfeld barely escapes from just dismissing him.
I mean isn't Karl literally just some random guy Ricky knew, not an actor or comedian at all, just a natural born weirdo that Ricky had a past relationship with? Would make sense that they would stay in touch.
Dominic Campbell
I think it's more a case of people who are cynical/analytical rather than bitter become atheists. You make it sound like people stop believing in God out of spite rather than actually thinking about it which is pretty stupid
Cooper Miller
That's not hema it's botn
Grayson Morales
>botn Oh wow, I could get into this. I'm guessing I would have to go to /asp/ to discuss this? That sucks.
We can discuss it on Cred Forums when it's on telly though, right? I bet a BOTN live thread on here would be a good laugh.
Anthony Martinez
>I think it's more a case of people who are cynical/analytical rather than bitter become atheists. You make it sound like people stop believing in God out of spite rather than actually thinking about it
Of the atheists in my friends in family, almost every single one had their "analytical breakthrough" IMMEDIATELY following a negative life event. One after his dad died, another after his sister committees suicude, etc. The only exception I can think of my brother, who has always been, you guessed it, bitter.
Maybe you're right about the cynicism, but not being analytical. Atheists believe that "I KNOW God isn't real". That is faith. You did not arrive at that conclusion through scientific thought. God is not falsifiable.
"An atheist has to know a lot more than I know. An atheist is someone who knows there is no god. By some definitions atheism is very stupid." -Carl Sagan
Christopher James
It airs live on youtube, sp and pol have threads up during the whole event It's a once a year thing and russia wins every time followed by the other slavic countries
Wyatt Powell
Thanks, I was hoping this would be the case. I assume that I have to wait until May for the next one. Gutted.
Anthony Brooks
>Godless heathen ends up in metaphorical lake of fire
It's like poetry
Camden Evans
Why do Americans insist on treating Atheism like a religion?
Matthew Long
Gervais is fucking finished
Liam Jackson
This is what happens when you shit on both God and the Devil.
Brody Rogers
I bet women love to know your herb-lore level
Jayden Perez
>Christians are officially taking over Cred Forums
Colton Thomas
You don't have to be Christian to dislike atheists user.
Robert Evans
Because it basically is, I guess. It requires you to believe in something despite having no proof.
Noah King
>implying
Atheists are not a very liked ideogical by anyone except other atheists, and even some of them hate how ridiculous atheism to be becoming.
Jaxson Powell
>It requires you not to believe in something you have no proof of. Fixed for you, stop being a cunt. Atheism is not becoming shit because it isn't a thing. People in america can be obnoxious sjw and call themselves atheists, it doesn't affect the lack of belief in divinities worldwide.
Adam Ross
>People in america can be obnoxious sjw and call themselves atheists, it doesn't affect the lack of belief in divinities worldwide.
I agree with this. People seem to think that if you are athiest you must also believe in all the other bullshit that some other athiests believes. It's like me saying that evangelists represent all Christians. It's dumb but some people here believe this.
Brandon Wilson
You're literally in denial. You "corrected" me for saying that atheists believe in something that have no proof in, even though it's true by definition. So you believe you have proof that God doesn't exist? THIS is why people treat it like a religion.
This is why everyone laughs when atheists act like their ideology makes them smart. To be fair, most aren't as delusional than you.
Jaxson Murphy
Lack of belief is not a belief, lack of proof is not proof, learn to read idiot. If you weren't lying to yourself you would make the same statement about every fictional idea ever. Your position is the laughable one, and only presented by american christian fundamentalists.
Hunter Williams
>I just want them 3 to give us a few more seasons of podcasts for the good old times. you and me, both, bud
Anthony Price
>The office was unique in it's time and good the first time you watch it, but ive never felt the urge to rewatch. The office was really influential I think, too. I think it helped paved the way for the non-laugh track sitcoms, to an extent? I know he in turn was influenced by This Is Spinal Tap, but bringing that feel to TV was really new, iirc.
I agree about Extras.
Austin Ortiz
>For Honor pvp
Juan Cooper
his hosting gigs were good. his stand up isn't bad. there was that comics discussing comedy thing with Seinfeld, Louis CK and Chris Rock... I know none of that's the same. I think he and Stephen are better as a team than either alone, for sure. And like the others, this is true for Stephen. But Hello Ladies had it's moments.
James Bennett
>, it doesn't affect the lack of belief in divinities worldwide
except religious belief is on the increase worldwide.
Aaron Wright
>Would be interesting to see Seinfeld do a nigger bit. yeah.
I give a lot of the credit for Seinfeld's success to Larry: youtu.be/iPnJ2tR2h_M
Jose Gomez
I guess that means Carl Sagan is a Christian fundamentalist?
If you are making an assertion (which atheism is), you must be able to back it up. You can't.
You aren't simply saying "I don't have faith in God" (agnosticism), you're saying "I know God doesn't exist", which is something you can't know.
Eli Fisher
regardless of anything else, that artwork is damn good. I'll say that much.
Camden Miller
That's not what the post meant (it's referring to the idea of scepticism being unaffected by anything people sharing the idea do). And the reason religion is on the rise is 100% because of muslims breeding like dogs while the atheist first world countries are below replacement rate. If you actually look at the data atheism is still on the rise in the west, just dropping as a global percentage.
Evan Jenkins
>If you are making an assertion (which atheism is) There is no assertion made in "I lack a belief".
Eli Baker
>Not being able to decide if gods could be real or not real >wise
Jayden Green
Agnosticism is a word literally made up to avoid the stigma of atheism. If you don't believe in god you're an atheist no need to pussy out "I don't know if gods exist but i have no faith in them" is just a roundabout way of going at it, it won't keep you from being beheaded.
Eli Cook
>2016 >not realizing atheism is a lack of beliefs
Colton Thomas
it's called being an agnostic-atheist I think?
fuck it, I was here to talk about Gervais Merchand and Pilk and their comedy.
later lads
Zachary Bailey
>trying to pretend atheism and agnosticism are synonyms
Agnosticism is saying you don't know. But atheism is saying you actively disbelieve.
Again, "An atheist has to know a lot more than I know. An atheist is someone who knows there is no god. By some definitions atheism is very stupid."
No one gives a flying fuck if you just don't happen to be religious. It's those who claim that they know religion is wrong that people have an issue with.
Liam Baker
>By some definitions Exactly Before the word agnosticism was made up, you had just atheists. Insisting that there is some incredible distinction from "don't have faith in gods": perfectly acceptable and "believe there is no gods": completely retarded, is asinine. People call themselves agnostics to take themselves out of the discussion and avoid flak, but agnosticism implies atheism. And everyone who knows the basics of world history knows religions are man made, new ones are born and old ones disappear all the time, everyone knows that no religious or mythical system is true, you just have faith.
Matthew Evans
Sounds like he is a JUST candidate
Jaxon Powell
Atheism just became too mainstream so it became cool to hate, even on Cred Forums which prides itself on doing what isn't cool. Most people here are atheists, they just do the whole "you can't know for certain" bullshit to avoid being painted as a fedora.
Colton Long
>Insisting that there is some incredible distinction from "don't have faith in gods": perfectly acceptable and "believe there is no gods": completely retarded, is asinine.
No, it's essential. There is a massive difference. One requires faith, the other doesn't.
I get that it would be convenient for you to assert that atheist and agnostics are the same thing, because it helps you create a "us vs them" thing, and gets more people on your side. But it requires you to throw out some pretty basic logic, and most of us aren't willing to do that.
Jayden Thompson
...
Chase Watson
If I define "God" as "everything that ever existed and will ever exist" then God exists by definition. There's a movement called Ignosticism, which posits that the whole question is meaningless until the completely ambiguous word "God" has been satisfactorily defined.
Jaxson Rogers
Both require lack of faith, one brings it to its logical conclusion Agnostics are in the non religious/filthy infidel group anyway, if there is an "us vs them" thing going on. What's really weird is your obsession with bringing agnostics on the side of the "wise" religious, while also claiming that atheism requires faith and of the two is the one which is secretly a religion.
Dominic Ross
I never thought he was funny outside some of his standup, even idiot abroad which I did like was more about pilkington and his reaction to stuff, whenever Ricky and the other guy came on to be a dick to him it was really annoying.
Mason Morgan
>But atheism is saying you actively disbelieve. There is no belief. "Lack of belief".
Isaiah Long
He a cunt. He is the kid who would start shit at school for attention. Who loved being a contrarian twat but was eager to tell you how not annoyed they where.
He's overly sensitive, aggressive and hypocritical. He'd cut people down for minor infractions.
Him and Stephen Fry are made of the same "dish it out, can't take it" material of self righteous twats with no actual self-awarness
Kayden Hernandez
Theists BELIEVE there is a God. Atheists BELIEVE that there is no God. Agnostics BELIEVE that they don't know if there is a God. Ignostics BELIEVE that none of the above even agree on what they mean by "God" so it's all meaningless arguing at cross purposes anyway.
Isaiah Williams
>Atheists BELIEVE Lack of belief.
I'm a neet so I don't mind posting this all day until you get it right.
Hudson Carter
I am not the guy you are arguing with, but you seem pretty stupid.
Jacob Morris
Do you have believe that there is no God? If yes, then you believe something you have no proof for.
>What's really weird is your obsession with bringing agnostics on the side of the "wise" religious
At no point in this thread have I EVER done that. I have never claimed that the religious are wise, nor have I tried to out agnostics on either "side". You have resorted to a blatant straw man. And what's worse, you this while replying to a comment I was actually COMPLAINING about people trying to put agnostics on a side.
You've gone from denial to outright "NO U!"
Gabriel Gray
Not according to Webster. Or Carl Sagan. Or the general public.
Chase Stewart
But you believe there's no god. Beliefs absolutely exist even as an atheist. You believe in scientists, you believe in their claims about the universe. You don't believe in religion, but you believe in everything everyone else says.
Or are you a nut who just pushes away literally everyone who tries to explain something, since they all must be wrong and evil?
Justin Scott
What do you think is the difference between an agnostic and an atheist?
Isaac Brown
Now, uuu
Brayden Flores
Lack of belief.
Tyler Evans
>proving a negative
Luis Walker
By definition you cannot have proof of the non existence of a fictional being that's beyond human understanding, which includes some gods. You still know they're not real by the context.
Sorry I thought "you're trying to bring agnostics on your side" meant you believed them to be on yours, since the way religion works you either have faith or you're an infidel, having multiple sides in the non religious field is what i was writing against in the last few posts. And I guess it was different people who kept posting the quote about wise people condemning atheism. No need to go on on a projecting rant.
Henry Rogers
Hundreds of millions? In 2016 it was reported he was only worth £49.2m. And that's including all assets. He probably only has £5-10m to his name.
Brayden Cook
Please don't start making up new words to self identify with, agnostic already only exist to feel superior to both sides, you add ignostic which is the same but being obnoxious about semantics that everyone is aware of, this pathetic.
Jayden Flores
though i didnt like cemetary junction i think it faired well critically and at the box office.
writing partners and groups take breaks all the time. that doesn't mean there's bad blood. i think it's more likely they're just doing their own shit. they're not fucking around in a radio booth anymore; they have new careers.
Camden Smith
Agnostics want to distantiate themselves from atheism initially to escape persecution nowadays to feel smug.
Angel Hall
I don't know a single person that finds this insufferable cunt funny. He's the worst part of every show he's on. Ricky Gervais Show was a great show because of Pilkington. Office was enjoyable because of everyone else. He's nothing but a leech.
David Miller
You don't have faith in scientifically proven facts, they're true regardless.
Benjamin Lee
>if you don't believe this one philosophical notion from a bronze age dick cutting desert tribe you must believe literally everyone is wrong and evil Holy shit you brain must be mush
Henry White
Karl was Ricky and Steve's producer on the XFM shows originally.
Kevin Adams
...
Xavier Ortiz
I don't argue with retards. You're better off just reading facts until you get it through your head, hence, lack of belief.
John Russell
Maybe he should pray
Eli Miller
This!
/thread
Brody King
There are many definitions even in the webster which is not a theological or philosophical encyclopaedia anyway so who gives a shit. And who gives a shit about fucking carl sagan too, who wrote "One of the great commandments of science is, "Mistrust arguments from authority."" >the general public is on my side >ad populum out of the ass lol
Leo Turner
Ignosticism is not new, I didn't make it up and I don't identify with it.
"Agnostic" exists to specify that one holds no belief either way, as opposed to theists and atheists who both believe (or claim to believe) that they KNOW the truth regarding the existence of God.
It's really not very complicated, but a surprising number of people seem to struggle with it. I guess it's just easier to grab a book and accept it as fact.
Aiden Lee
>distantiate Scientologist detected.
Henry Robinson
>muh lack of belief >muh lack of belief >muh lack of belief >hurr i'm winning!! >but not against retards hurr
You're legitimately mental, dude.
Nathaniel Torres
Chris Rock is a generic black comic, stealing from Pryor's grave, no originality, just hackneyed race and relationship shit shouted in a manlet voice.
Seinfeld is literally autistic, everything funny came from Larry David.
Ricky at least used to be funny, these two never were. So tired of people parroting opinions on this video, seems like nobody talked about it for 5 years, then in the last 6 months I've heard 3 podcasts that say Ricky was a fish out of water and didn't deserve to wash the sandals of the living god Chris Rock.
Charles Davis
>Ignosticism is not new from wikipedia >The term ignosticism was coined in the 1960s by Sherwin Wine, a rabbi That's just as new as tumblr genders, fuck that and fuck you for bringing it up.
Ryder Long
You can greentext all you want, you still can't explain how a person lacking belief can believe either way so instead you keep trying to change the definition so it fits in your made up argument.
Lack of belief.
Zachary Hughes
So when you discuss whether God exists or not, you just assume everyone is on the same page re: the word "God?" Here:
Let's say my definition of God is: "Everything that exists in the present moment." DOES GOD EXIST Y/N?
Justin Lee
"Lack of belief" could describe either an atheist or an agnostic. Neither believe in God. Can you be more specific?
Dylan Davis
Anyone discussing the existence of god in any seriousness would first give their definition, usually it's the one given by one of the main religions. This is literally a smarmy rabbi making up shit in the 60s, "what if my god is my dick, makes you think uh?" Fuck you for being so easily impressed.
Sebastian Thomas
>Neither believe in God. Lack of belief. You still want to make it seem as if atheists choose one alternative or the other. They choose neither.
Zachary Harris
>is presented with evidence that he is wrong >simply repeats the same claim over again as if saying something multiple times makes it true
Your first sentence is incorrect. You're basically trying to tell me that all hypothetical beings are not falsifiable. But this is not true. You're also saying you determine what is real based on "context" rather than proof. Are you sure you're not religious?
>Sorry I thought "you're trying to bring agnostics on your side" meant you believed them to be on yours What side do you think I'm on?
>since the way religion works you either have faith or you're an infidel, having multiple sides in the non religious field is what i was writing against in the last few posts. so you ARE making this into "us vs to them", and painting "them" as a cartoon stereotype. Even though everyone here knows that is incorrect. We all know some religious people that are good have man beings. Your insistance that all good people are non-religious, and all religious people are book-burning witch hunters with no exceptions is not doing your credibility any favors. Hell, I can cite you multiple examples of Methodists alone being remarkably inclusive and respectful of atheists, from inviting them to speak at sermons, to saying good atheists are better than bad Christians.
>And I guess it was different people who kept posting the quote about wise people condemning atheism. You said I was siding with "'wise' religious" people. Carl Sagan is not religious, he's agnostic
Honestly, you're a strong case for a high amount of bitterness among atheists, since you hate everyone else, from the religious (all of them) to agnostics.
You're like an SJW. You're militant with your ideology, you believe you're better than everyone else (despite calling THEM smug), you think the whole world is out to get you, and you believe anyone that disagrees with you must hate you.
Jace Kelly
>You still want to make it seem as if atheists choose one alternative or the other. No, atheists choose not to believe in God, right? But it's possible to go one further and say you BELIEVE there is NO GOD. What do you call someone who makes that step? And what do you call someone who refuses to make that step?
>>is presented with evidence that he is wrong Lack of belief. You still have to concede you're wrong about this for me to even accept your existence in this thread.
Adrian Davis
>No, atheists choose not to believe in God, right? They choose to lack that belief.
Brayden Green
You're literally repeating your belief over and over again while we've cited reputable sources that dispute it.
>CREATIONISM IS REAL >CREATIONISM IS REAL >CREATIONISM IS REAL >CREATIONISM IS REAL >I REFUSE TO DEBATE YOU UNTIL YOU AGREE WITH ME
See how ridiculous that is? That is what you are doing.
Leo Lewis
>it's so popular to hate ricky gervais now that Cred Forums is defending him
literally never thought i'd see people defending this total loser. he has never done anything good. UK office is probably one of the worst comedy shows i've ever watched. Completely devoid of actual emotion.
Adam Murphy
>You're literally repeating your belief My lack of belief.
Adrian Sullivan
You are repeating that atheism means "lack of belief. You refuse to respond to this
Not him but fuck Merriam-webster. Noice is not a fucking word.
Ryan Allen
So I shown you evidence that the definition of athiest is not "lack of belief in a God", and provided you with evidence from a reputable source that said that the decision is actual a belief in the non-existence of a god.
...and your response is to highlight that evidence and type btfo in all caps?
I guess this is part where you try damage control and say you were "PRETENDING to be retarded", huh?
All you see capable of doing is screaming "I'M RIGHT I'M RIGHT I'M RIGHT I'M RIGHT" without refuting what the rest of are saying. Now you aren't even making an attempt. I've given you the evidence. I can't force you to respond to it. And now you're forcing us to walk away with another example of an athiest who can't support his beliefs and simply screams at people for daring to present arguments he can't refute. I hope when I leave, you stop trying to save face and start using some of those critical thinking skills you claim to value.
Julian Brooks
>Confirmation Bias: The Post
Hunter Jenkins
> all hypothetical beings are not falsifiable Only all hypothetical beings that have in their definition "beyond human understanding". Again: Learn to read. > determine what is real based on "context" rather than proof Context is proof you fucking idiot, what sort of fucked up definition of proof are you using, you find shit coming out of an anus, but that's just it's context, i need furrther proof that's not chocolate, just choke on it already. >you ARE making this into "us vs to them", and painting "them" as a cartoon stereotype You are the one who brought up "us vs them" I'm only replying to you, the division between faithful and infidel is very real and people are being killed over it it has nothing to do with cartoons you disingenuous shitnugget >everyone is n my side argument again >all good people are non-religious, and all religious people are book-burning witch hunters with no exceptions Holy shit I never even said anything about good and evil or burning books you madman >Methodists alone being remarkably inclusive and respectful of atheists Being invited to a sermon doesn't make the distinction between believers and not believers less objective
>you're a sjw nonargument I don't hate anyone in the world. I'm not militant about anything. I have a massive inferiority complex. I'm not paranoid and am obviously ok with having arguments. Could you possibly strawman any harder? You should be ashamed of yourself.
Juan Harris
>only link he presents is the one that conveniently change the entire concept of atheism Really makes me scratch my noggin. Lack of belief.
Anthony Gutierrez
>you hate everyone else
>you believe anyone that disagrees with you must hate you
You must realise you're talking about yourself right?
Isaiah Baker
I'm genuinely not the guy who kept repeating "lack of belief."
I made and posted that pic, and said he was BTFO, unironically. I genuinely want lack of belief guy to TRY NOW because his "argument" is woebegone to the max.
Jose Campbell
I never had experience with a religion myself but everyone I met that I knew their religion aside a few Catholics let their religion define them. This is especially true about people in niche religions.
They become walking memes and I hate them.
Ian Russell
>evidence from a reputable source >single eight word definition from an online dictionary >ignoring previous replies explaining how the webster is not an academic source You're hopeless.
Bentley Cooper
>context IS proof! Then explain this: >By definition you cannot have proof of the non existence of a fictional being that's beyond human understanding, which includes some gods. You still know they're not real by the context.
Those are your words. You've literally just reversed your opinion.
Caleb Perry
What is the difference between an atheist and an agnostic?
Cooper Jackson
>Merriam-Webster is not a reputable source >neither is Carl Sagan >but me screaming "lack of belief" over and over again is
Are you literally a child?
Kevin Turner
Nope. Please point to where I have said that.
Christopher Hernandez
99% of atheists become atheists when they are thought about the history of religions or when they are old enought o realize the contraddictions in the holy texts, which is usually during childhood. Which was the case for both Ricky and Louie btw. Atheists who renounce god after somebody dies are a stereotype from fucking chick tracts and those people aren't even really atheists.
Jayden Gray
>Being invited to a sermon doesn't make the distinction between believers and not believers less objective Well can you show the widespread occurance of Methodists calling atheists "infidels"?
Hunter Parker
underrated post
Adam Flores
>those people aren't even really atheists. >No-true-Scotsman fallacy
You're not just a laugh- you're a riot!
Jacob Anderson
>implying i am that guy >still ignoring carl sagan literally warning people against arguments from authority >still defending a shitty 8 words web definition as an academic source Kill yourself asap
Angel Brooks
baby dead.
Nathan White
The context is the meta. You can't be so stupid come on. If a book describes a being beyond human knowledge, you still know it's not really real because you know that some dude just wrote that book from his imagination.
Dylan Mitchell
he's rich af does it even matter
Brayden Nguyen
So you are claiming that you know God was made up by man? You're justification for "I know God isn't real" is "God was made by man". Do you not see the circular logic here? You're verifying a claim by making the same claim.
Jaxson Barnes
Those are direct quotes, reread your own post. You accuse me of hating everyone that i disagree with and in the next sentence that i believe everyone who disagrees with me hates me. That's a very peculiar belief to have, textbook projecting.
Asher Green
infidel is latin for faithless
Logan Barnes
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atheism >In an even narrower sense, atheism is specifically the position that there are no deities.
UH OH
Alexander Carter
So, you STILL have not provided ANY evidence that your definition is correct, while I have provided multiple pieces of evidence that mine is. If you refuse to actual refute anything, I'm done with you.
Matthew Jackson
They're not in the sense that they're just christians going trough a spiritual crisis. An atheist is not just a bad/lost christian. Not a scotsman fallacy. That's not circular at all. Reread and think about it please.
Noah Kelly
You quoting my accusation, and then essentially said "no u", but you have not pointed out where I claimed that everyone that disagrees with me hates me or where I said I hated everyone that disagrees with me.
Camden Barnes
>I believe there is no God, so I'm an athiest >nope >why not? >because I can read your mind. You're really just a Christian. You see, if you were an athiest, that would imply atheists aren't morally superior. But since your existence hurts my worldview, I'm going to declare you a Christian. Bad people are Christians. >but I wasn't even Christian, I was jew- >shut up. You are no true athiest, despite being an athiest by definition
Hey, you know all those Christians you hate for being inferior to you? They're not really Christians.
Hudson Sanchez
Every single one of those sources lists the lack of beliefs, only two alternatives, definition as the first or the second one. It's the definition widely current in the history of thought even.
Nathaniel Fisher
Read the definition of projecting. By making such a weird claim with no reason you show your own vulnerability.
Mason Thompson
>I don't know have proof that God isn't real, but I believe it because I know that man made him
That would be proof. But it doesn't really matter, since you don't have proof that he was made by man. You're screaming your beliefs over and over and hoping people will give up poking holes in it. Wish granted. I'm going to go argue with a brick while. At least a brick wall can't make arguements as terrible as yours and back them up by repeating them over and over without ever refuting their flaws.
Noah Price
It doesn't matter what was the starting religion the argument still stands. And again i never made any statements about good or evil nor superiority. How old are you?
Gavin Sullivan
But it doesn't have the same definition in English, and you still haven't shown widespread use of it among Methodists.
Jace Bell
>people >implying it's not just your mentally unhinged self repeating the same busted fallacies only to ignore the rebuttal again and again the projecting is outstanding
Andrew Kelly
non religious, faithless, infidel, atheist, agnostic are synonyms for the sake of the argument (in that they all imply lack of faith) >widespread use of it among Methodists was never part of the argument stop being literally autistic
Nathan Carter
>Every single one of those sources lists the lack of beliefs No, it doesn't say "lack of belief". It says "Belief that there is no God". Read it.
Hunter Nelson
So it's not all religious people? It's specifically groups like fundamentalists?
Kayden Foster
>non religious, faithless, infidel, atheist, agnostic are synonyms for the sake of the argument Are you fucking kidding? These have WILDY different definitions and contexts! It's like saying "a square and a rectangle are the same thing because they both have four straight sides"
Colton Moore
Infidel is an insult. Faithless is not. Plus, faithless is a completely accurate term.
Christopher Ross
You're either impossibly stupid or impossibly shameless.
Anthony Green
>since you don't have proof that he was made by man It's called Occam's Razor, bud. It's funny that people aren't badgered to justify non-belief in other fantastical beings.
Joshua Scott
The only one of those that is considered an authority is Oxford. And it's on the same level as Webster. So all you have done is shown that there is a disagreement on the definition. Which we already knew.
Michael Sanders
Not THE definition widely current in the history of though... The LESS RIGOROUS definition (though widely current etc). The former (ie. primary) meaning of the term is a LITERAL rendering. Are you not LITERALLY an atheist?
Your definition of atheism includes UNINFORMED CHILDREN. Do you really think that UNINFORMED CHILDREN consciously identify as atheists as opposed to theists? Why bother declaring yourself to be of the default position held by UNINFORMED CHILDREN user?
But the main argument here, is that THERE ARE TWO MAIN DEFINITIONS OF ATHEISM IN PHILOSOPHY. "Lack of belief" is one (and the secondary/broad one by most wiki sources). You flatly denied the existence of any other definition, stubbornly repeating the words "Lack of belief" as your entire argument. You were proven wrong.
user, what if you're wrong about God, too?
Josiah Watson
>Occam's Razor, bud. That's not proof. You are literally making an assumption. All Occam's Razor does is say "ignore variables that you can't measure or test". And it was invented by a monk.
>It's funny that people aren't badgered to justify non-belief in other fantastical beings. >non-belief There you go again. Trying to imply that lack of belief in something and belief that something doesn't exist are the same thing.
Henry Long
gotta charge my phone. Be back for babby's first theological discussion in a few hours
Ayden Anderson
>in a few hours And they never heard from him again.
Matthew Myers
Have you got any proof about all that greentext nonsense op? If not, let the cunt play with his cat.
Dylan Wright
The disagreement is meaningless though since next to zero atheists "believe there is no god." Whenever people argue that atheism means "belief there is no god" they're just insisting that some people believe something they don't believe so they can beat up a strawman and paint atheists as, at the very worst, as delusional as religious people are. Which is a fucking funny "argument" coming from a religious apologist anyway.
Camden Watson
>>All of his recent projects have bombed or been panned by critics and public or at least fallen into mediocrity territory you mean like all of his projects?
he was never funny.
Elijah Lewis
Ricky's always been cunt, it's only taken you fedora fags to realise this now because what he espouses is stale.
Ryder Perry
Not the OP, but the last three are objective facts.
Joseph Ramirez
>richard dawkins declared himself an agnostic in his book the god delusion What did he mean by this?
Seriously, I'll ask you a third and final time: What is the difference between an agnostic and an atheist?
Eli Green
It's what happens when you publicly denounce God and talk about how cool it is to be an atheist
He's been struck down
Adrian Young
what a pauper
Adam Ward
>Ricky also had a special relationship with celebrities like Jonathan Ross and left Steve out of that Do you think he did that because Merchant left Ricky out of his (Steve's) special relationship with Hayley Atwell?
Benjamin King
No one ever publicly denounced god or said it was cool to be an atheist. God just doesn't exist in the form claimed by most theistic religions, and in any other form it literally doesn't matter.
Jackson Williams
...
Wyatt Wood
An agnostic believes it can never be known for sure if God exists or not, an atheist doesn't believe God exists. Get schooled, kid.
Brody Clark
>never said it was cool to be an athiest >Had an entire stand up routine based around it >tried to interject it randomly into his show with Karl
I think most people in media realise it was a mistake to prop him up this high because 80% hold some form of belief in a higher power
Aiden Perry
You're butthurt and insecure because not everyone is a gullible moron who will believe anything as long as it's written in a "really old book™. Zombies? Check. Fairies? Check. A magical universe creator who poofed into existence a space 100+ billion light years in diameter so he could make sure the organisms evolving on one infinitesimal rock don't masturbate or eat pork? Check. Violations of logic, the laws of physics, and everything in between? Check. Religious people tending to be poor, uneducated, and stupid? Check. Oh, all of that is written in A Really Old Book™? I believe it!
Justin Bennett
That doesn't mean he did it because it's cool, he did it because it's hilariously absurd that so many of you are so gullible and unintelligent. It's funny. It's the exact equivalent of believing Lord of the Rings is historical non-fiction. You think you should be exempt from being made fun of? You're a fucking idiot. Kill yourself, you obese lunatic.
Oliver Lopez
there's a difference between "believing" a true, undeniable fact and believing in utter nonsense fairy tales without a shred of provability, merit or remote possibility
Alexander Garcia
This is why atheism is the worst religion.
Owen Williams
>Not understanding the value of the truth within myth and the shared experience of culture, 2016, and that very few Christians are actual young earthers who believe it literally.
Yet here you are on Cred Forums
Easton Bell
All I can say to that is
>*tips fedora*
Landon Carter
Claiming some arbitrary selection of the Bible is "just a metaphor" doesn't exempt you from needing to prove the validity of whichever parts of it you claim aren't a metaphor. Everyone already knows religious people cope with modern analyticism by vaguely mumbling the word "metaphor." It doesn't add any credibility to your fantasies or delusions. And I don't give a shit about shared culture, that too adds no credibility to your claims.
Lucas Thomas
Polytheism/Paganism was on the money desu senpai.
Christian Howard
>the proponents of the second definition, by contrast, regard the first definition as too broad because it includes uninformed children along with aggressive and explicit atheists. consequently, it is unlikely that the public will adopt it Who are the "proponents" this passage is referring to then? Religious people who want to pin atheists down to a position they can argue against? Whoever they are, I think they have a point, don't you? If your definition includes everyone who doesn't believe in God, that's so broad as to be virtually meaningless.
According to this site, someone who claims to know there are no Gods is a "gnostic" atheist, and the other type (doesn't believe but doesn't claim to know) is an "agnostic" atheist. So there we go. Next time, instead of spamming "Lack of belief!" like a broken record, you can now simply specify which kind of atheist you are and save everyone some time.
Zachary Long
And that's just it. You don't give a shit. You've unilaterally decided that you have all the answers (or, that there are no answers) and are perfectly content with a nothingless void after a few decades (if we're lucky).
Does being smug and calling others delusional just part of your charm, or are you a multi-faceted ass? (maybe he's good at chess or something)
Dominic Nguyen
I read this in Ricky Gervais's voice.
Jacob Evans
Your lack of belief still constitutes a belief in and of itself.
Sorry bro, you tried
Julian Phillips
Not all the answers, just ones that require basic coherence of mind.
>and are perfectly content with
Objective reality has nothing to do with contentment. How I feel about what happens after death has nothing remotely to do with what happens after death.
Logan Hill
>How I feel about what happens after death has nothing remotely to do with what happens after death.
Right back at ya.
Hudson Garcia
>user posts a picture of Ricky being crazy about being an athiest >respond by flipping the fuck out and going on a incoherent rant about you hate religion
I-it was just picture, dude.
Blake Martin
I bet he's great fun at parties, lol.
Nicholas Harris
>being this sensible I wouldn't waste the energy
Camden Butler
>Your lack of belief still constitutes a belief Hey, "lack of belief" guy here. I didn't have the patience to get this particular sentence out of you but I'm glad someone else did. Anyways, you're wrong.
Jeremiah Peterson
so what? did you read it correctly?
>An agnostic believes it can never be known for sure if God exists or not, an atheist doesn't believe God exists.
they both believe things
also your point is null anyway because it's a paradox
Jaxson Bell
If belief in something is built through a series of combined and subjective experiences which are ultimately catalyzed by factors outside of any one individuals control, is the belief, regardless of what it asserts, relevant to anyone other than the individual itself? And therefore unimportant to the rest of society at large, unless it serves some practical purpose?