Be honest, Cred Forums. Be savage and brutal. Tell me every flaw, everything you hate no matter how big or small.
Too many people I know are drinking the kool-aid and it's making me puke.
I need this place now more than ever.
Leo Roberts
It looks pretty good so far
Luke Ramirez
It's going to a popcorn flick as all Star Wars movies are. All previous SW movies are within 2 points of each other on a 1-10 scale. Clone Wars is the worst of the bunch at 4/10 and Revenge of the Sith and Empire Strikes back are 6/10.
Rogue One will probably be in the the middle somewhere. The only thing going for it, is that it has Mads and Luna.
Joseph Jones
Is that the real poster? The stormtroopers look horrible.
Alexander Fisher
Meant attack of the Clones, Clone Wars is the best thing the series has made and I would say it's a 7/10.
Jose Perez
>Empire Strikes back are 6/10 I agreed with your statement until that point.
Zachary Thomas
lower?
Nathan Edwards
Usually the reshoots are a sign of flawed movie.
It's going to be Suicide Squad tier bad, even though RT score will be above 80%.
Jonathan Wilson
Jesus Christ, dude... you care way too much about this movie.
Landon Price
Its starshit, worse than TFA, maybe even worse than AotC.
VIII is the absolute last chance for Disney to prove they are serious about star wars and arent just turning it into their marvel 2.0, but I doubt anything good will come of it and the franchise will continue to be raped.
Lucas selling it was a mistake.
Connor Murphy
>How hard is this going to suck? Doesn't look like it will, although I'd like Felicity to suck me, if you know what I mean.
Levi Ward
I didn't make this thread for reddit tourists.
Cred Forums thoughts only please.
Ian Sanchez
The director is creatively bankrupt hack who couldn't make a good movie out of the best script or concept imaginable. He has proven this with Monsters and Godzilla.
It will be maybe twenty minutes of entertaining, interesting, or engaging action and set pieces, poorly sprinkled through an hour and a half of plodding exposition and shitty camerawork (read: handheld for shot/reverse shot conversations). The characters will be one-note and forgettable, with producers expecting their distinctive races to substitute for personalities, while being the only thing that makes them memorable and sells toys (see: Mace Windu in the prequels).
It will be hailed as bloated and boring by critics and fans. Disney will try and fail to salvage the clusterfuck Gareth Edwards created with reshoots and clever advertising but the movie will be a big, loud thud. It won't even make that much money because normies don't understand fuckall about the timeline of the movies.
In a few years, it will go down as the worst spin off movie and the dullest thing to come from the new movie universe. It will probably kill the other planned spinoffs except the Han Solo or Boba Fett ones. Idiots will praise it for being uneventful and tonally fucked and toss it in with the prequels as "misunderstood kino".
Tyler Anderson
It's gonna be great.
Jack Torres
Also, 62% on RT. Screencap this.
Lucas Barnes
>Screencap this. kill yourself
Jace Murphy
Close, eccept that my, and others who like them's claim is that the prequels are merely about on par with the OT. The prequels are underrated and the OT is over rated. Correctingg for this, they come out evenly.
Contrary to popular belief, the filmmaking is at the slim level in every movie other than Empire, which is technically exellent.
Benjamin Taylor
*except im failry drunk
Lucas Bell
To be fair they look horrible in the movie. If they looked like shit in the OT it's because those movies are decades old. The ones in TFA look good, don't break my suspension of disbelief whatsoever. These ones look like they're made from cheap plastics and rubber.
Xavier Stewart
i remember being 14
Lincoln Thompson
literally every movie has reshoots. they budget for it. stop acting like you know anything about the industry
Ethan Myers
you are clinically retarded if you think the prequels compare at all to the originals
Jaxson Sullivan
his godzilla movie was the best one in the entire franchise, you weeb faggot
Brody Bailey
All the movies are shit-mediocre. The animated series was alright. If anyone is 14 around here, it's the people who genuinely like these movies (OT, PT, or reboot).
Ethan Kelly
...
John Turner
>movie isn't out yet >Be honest, Cred Forums. Be savage and brutal. Tell me every flaw, everything you hate no matter how big or small.
excuse me?
Brandon Harris
So, when are they gonna make a pro-Empire/Sith movie?
Fucking Jedi's.
Hunter Robinson
They seem determined to diversify the fuck out of the casts of these movies.
I guess it makes sense. People from different parts of the galaxy are gonna look diff.
I can't say I don't want to see more diversity, but it seemed forced...no pun intended.
Owen Johnson
i rebel
Carter Adams
well, the cinematography and pacing are on point, perhaps character development is a bit off, but the shading will definitely make up for it
Eli King
>already time for the next daily rogue1 autist poster thread Christ.
Isaac Carter
Fuck off. It's going to be good. TFA was a great experience. It wasn't the best movie but it was a top-notch movie-going experience and Rogue One will be too. I go to them to eat popcorn and get taken to a galaxy far far away.
Elijah Young
> that cast D I V E R S E I V E R S E
James Cruz
I'm afraid this user will be right
Monsters was fantastic though
Jose White
Can we all make a collective agreement to not posts Star Wars threads for the next few days so we can see how many Disney-shills are on Cred Forums?
Kevin Hernandez
No we can't and there are none. I assure you Disney doesn't give a fuck about the opinion of Cred Forums.
Jayden Phillips
The only reason I'm giving the jew mouse my money is because I know if I don't see it in IMAX I won't like it a whole lot. Anyone else have a similar mindset?
Michael Wood
Here's a game for you Cred Forums
Without re-watching the Trailer. Tell me some qualities of the music for Rogue One.
Kayden Barnes
>changing the male character to female >vader not killing the rebels >the asian actors feel like they are being cast very stereotypical >the stupid "POWAH" performance by that white guy was badly acted in the trailer and felt that it came off as a parody
Jacob Brown
>Dis a rebellion isn't it? >But rebels are built on hope Why is her lines cringey?
Daniel Kelly
Every movie with cgi landscapes and effects looks the same these days...
When I was watching the trailer it could have just as easily been game of thrones graphics just with space things
and all of them have this little blurriness
Bentley Jenkins
>All previous SW movies are within 2 points of each other on a 1-10 scale There he is. There's the "smart" fence sitter everybody. No real opinion at all.
Aaron Thomas
Can't they make spaceships practical like they did in the 80's?
Jacob Hughes
...
Colton Perry
>Star Wars universe >finally a good cast >initially not made for babies
too bad they made reshots, still looks promising.
Sebastian Gray
Fucking hell. Looks like TFA was lightning in a bottle. Back to Marvel level of production values.
Alexander Baker
TFA was stupid
and all other star wars movies with be marvel 2.0 but with literal 10/10 beautiful women
calling it ... now!
Liam Hall
A lot. Simply because nobody can write a good dialogue anymore.
Daniel Williams
>10/10 beautiful women
Aaron Diaz
SPOILERS
jyn is a toaster
Nathaniel Ortiz
who said this was ok
Easton Young
>TFA was stupid Irrelevant. It looks fantastic. Better than capeshit. Better than Jurassic Shit. Better than any other blockbuster. Rogue One will no doubt be horribly written but the fact that it looks blurry and has shitty CGI and laughable choreography just kills all interest for me. The Donnie stick fights look super fake and the firefight where they're running towards that ship looks like a tv show.
Rogue One looks like it could be as high as a 7/10, fingers crossed. Hopefully Episodes 8 and 9 will be even better, but I'm not getting my hopes up quite yet.
Charles Hall
I will never forget the moment she uttered the phrase "I rebel." in the first trailer.
Now I want it in the movie since it's confirmed utter shit.
Gabriel Hill
They imitated some of the ep 4 luke theme.
Logan Mitchell
Kill yourself retard.
Daniel Gonzalez
This looks like the worst movie ever, what the fuck are you on?
>TFA >better than anything I'll give you it was better than Hobbit 3, but that was the only movie I've ever walked out of the theater during. Should have walked out of the theater for Star Wars too, but hindsight is 20/20.
Xavier Clark
Nice nostalgia goggles you faggot
Jose Garcia
>Han Solo I'm so disgusted they're making this.
Chase Foster
>stop acting like you know anything about the industry It was widely reported they were adding more humour and other shit to make it more family friendly. fuck you.
Thomas Lee
>TFA better than prequels Yeah, nice try, capeshit aficionado.
Adrian Lee
>Fuck off. It's going to be good. TFA was a great experience. It wasn't the best movie but it was a top-notch movie-going experience HUUURRR turn your brain off bro
Lucas Jenkins
Which console exclusive is this from?
Ethan Myers
If they can't make a movie you're going to like in the first place you shouldn't be giving them any money at all. Let alone extra money
Xavier Nguyen
We will never a get apocalypse now inspired star wars movie directed by Gareth Edwards
Austin Flores
>TFA was lightning in a bottle You're human garbage.
Grayson James
>I won't enjoy it unless I pay extra Literal sheep.
Carson White
It's a visual medium you fucking baby.
Ayden Thomas
You're a retarded cuck user. These movies are being made for people just like you.
John Murphy
>Tell me every flaw of this movie, based on 5 minutes from three trailers. You really are trying hard to make us bekive you really hate star wars. You must be fun to be around
Anthony Russell
Judging by the director, it's going to be bad.
Hudson Howard
He's making the same thread every day. He's a false flag shill.
Luke Reed
well hopefully they won't have a peasant girl beat an experienced jedi like in the other """star wars""" failure
Henry Gomez
Bruh the movie hasn't even come out yet
Austin Kelly
I remember being 12.
Juan Parker
We are literally the most analytic and in-depth film discussion forum on the Internet, probably the largest too, you are stupid if you don't think the major studios keep an eye on what we say here.
Robert Edwards
>We are literally the most analytic and in-depth film discussion forum on the Internet
holy fuck he really meant that unironically lmao prepare for multiple (You)'s
Austin Taylor
The sole reason for this movie to exist is to bait the chinese market to hop on the Star Wars train.
Shit's pathetic yo
Luis Ramirez
>nostalgia googles >practically rates ep 7 the highest >??????????
Dylan Butler
2/10 not diverse enough
Isaiah Gonzalez
iRebelle, new from Apple, this spring
alternatively, Ira Bell, inventor of rebellion
Christian Johnson
her metal teeth are an homage to Moonraker
Grayson Peterson
Felicity Jones is aging like milk
Ian Price
They shouldn't have made Donnie Yen's character blind. That's stupid.
Charles Turner
Star Wars: teenage angst
Nathaniel Thomas
Jyn Erso is a ripoff of the Star Wars character Jan Ors. The writers changed a few letters, called it a day and cashed in their multi-million dollar checks.
That is the level of creativity the writers hired by Disney are capable of.
Gavin Murphy
It won't suck. It'll be generic and very average.
John Sanders
Preposterous, the affirmative action alone gives it a 70-75%, top that of with the teenage angst in this movie and it will be at least an 85%. Not based on merit, but based on (((feelings))) for a """nerd""" series
Dominic Martinez
episode 7 is basically 4, so no wonder you like it you nostalgia baby.
Anthony Evans
I'll like it better than 7, probably better than the prequels too. 5>4>6>R>3>1>2>7 will probably be how it shapes up.
Josiah Ramirez
They had room in the budget for two asians and a muslim but not one woman of color? And the only female role (the lead) goes to a white woman?
Bravo Disney.
Jose Adams
>It will be hailed as bloated and boring by critics and fans.
don't be retarded, critics will give it a good score due to the diversity
Aaron Jackson
Star Wars is just Hungry Bird teenage girl-power now, no reason to pay attention to it unless you are a female in high school looking for a role model.
I'd watch it just for spaceship and shit. I'll watch Rogue One just for At-At's and At-St's.
Brody Green
Looks like pure kino judging from the trailer. Thank Disney for saving the franchise
Jackson Wilson
I have no idea because I'm not going to watch it. I got burned bad by """""Episode VII""""". I'll never watch another one of these nu/Wars/ piles of shit again.
Isaiah Torres
What do you think lightning in a bottle means you fucking retard?
Carter Gray
Literally EU: the movie
If you want to watch this feminist toy commercial for any other reason but to shitpost about it you need to stop being such a goyim and become a fucking individual already
Andrew Young
>Episode 1: 1/10 Dumb 4U faggot. Episode 1 was the second best film in the series. The only reason people hate it is because it's not one of the original trilogy and everyone's trying to be a fucking hipster. Episode IV is best, 1 is second, everything else from the original series and prequels gets worse from there. Jedi was actually the worst before these new abominations.
>7 >6/10 Kill your rancid, prepubescent self.
Ryder Smith
Objectively the best Star Wars movie ever made.
Oliver Hill
>if my opinion is not reinforced, then he must be from reddit
Dominic Young
Speaking of that, I was at Disney Springs yesterday and my girlfriend dragged me into the Star Wars store (why do girls pretend to like Star Wars). Anyway, HALF the merch in the store was Rogue 1 shit. Typical garbage.
Only cool stuff in the whole shop was some original artwork they wanted 2k for.
Colton Reyes
>The POWAH we are dealing with here is immeasurable
What did he mean by this? Is this related to the legendary UN-LIMITED POWAH Sheev once spoke of?
Luis Perez
>only white male in the poster is the villain What did disney mean by this?
Michael Jones
>only black male in the poster is the villain What did Burton mean by this?
Easton Bailey
OI u Focking wOt kunt U tellen mE Me fooKen Built D fooking Deathstar.
>ESB 6/10 Get out you retard, ESB is at its worse a 9/10
Camden Nguyen
>arent just turning it into their marvel 2.0 You cant be this naive
Hunter Sanders
Wow so mature, have your (you) *tips fedora* 8^)
Ian Hernandez
TIM "if its a nigger pull the tigger" BURTON
Eli Hernandez
retard they looked good in the ot, because they were created for it. Stormtroopers are literally the only thing they kept the same for rogue 1 and they look out of place af
Camden Roberts
Yes, its also the same POOOWAH FROM THE DAAAARK SSIDE Vader wanted Luke to know about