The great debate

The great debate

There's literally no debate
3 only had 2, tops 3 good songs while GH2 was fucking BANGING and was able to be moded to have custom tracks.

>trying to do Psychobilly Freakout on Expert

2 had a better soundtrack. The only reason people loved 3 was because "omg TTFAF hardest song evar".

And even then, World Tour had a better setlist than either of them.

nigga you could mod 3 for custom tracks

what the hell are you shilling for

Guitar Hero 3 was better.

Guitar Hero 2 had no challenge at all and no personality.

2
>way better soundtrack

3
>better gameplay

if you don't have a space if your heart for both you're stupid

Guitar Hero 2

2 had the better soundtrack.

3 had the better gameplay.

ILL SEND AN SOS TO THE WORLD
ILL SEND AN SOS TO THE WORLD
ILL SEND AN SOS TO THE WORLD
I HOPE THAT SOMEONE GETS MY
I HOPE THAT SOMEONE GETS MY
I HOPE THAT SOMEONE GETS MY

2 had more/better metal while three had better rock and indie stuff

that's not even shilling you fucking imbecile. You should pay attention in your fucking English class so you can read properly enough to know what that word means.


>trying to shill a game thats almost 10 years old

You're the one shilling making up false facts to make guitar hero 2 look better.

IE: A SHILL

AKA KILL YOURSELF

I like GH2 more

I miss you, Neversoft

WoR with everything Imported.

Aside that GH2, GH3 have a huge ass timing window because of new engine.

I still remember how goddamn shitty the charting for a lot of the songs in 3 was. Holy shit, can you think of a more obnoxious chart than those single notes in Before I Forget being charted as whole G-Y, R-B, Y-O chords towards the end? Although I'll give GH3 a little credit by making Judy a titty monster, though.

>tfw trying to FC Cliffs of Dover and Judy starts jumping in the background

BARACUDDA
*cue 4 miles of green notes*

>trying to find a usb guitar for GH3custom and phase shift
>they are all expensive as fuck and broken

Xbox guitars also work on PC.

I have been looking at them as well, I'd like the Xplorer guitar but do rock band guitars work with GH3 and PS?

Yes they do. I'm not sure about GH3 but seems that they work on every game past WT.

Tfw I bought GH Live

The new guitar is actually fun to learn. Pretty good buy if you find it for $60 or less. GHTV is also a pretty good idea too.

I also bought RB4 but that was a crock of shit

>Raining blood on expert.

Smash hits chart kinda lower the difficult, but, final note is FC killer.

>SO FAR AWAY WE WAIT FOR THE DAY

Rocksmith

2.

3 was more refined in away in terms of game play and graphics, but lost some of the Guitar Hero charm. 3 also had few good songs. 2 has a lot of memorable songs.

Also this . 3 overcharted as fuck. Another I can think of is Cherub rock being nothing but triple note shit.

I dunno man they're both pretty sick. I found III made the hammer ons and pull offs a lot easier to hit than II somehow. I have more nostalgia for II but having Slash and the Devil and God and God's sick axe were all really cool extras in III and it had lots of great tracks too.

But I mean even if they're mostly cover versions, II's soundtrack just can't be beat. And it may not have had as any cool axes and characters as III for extras but all i ever needed in II was the Jimmy Page facsimile character with the EDS-1275 anyway.

>2, tops 3 good songs

Cliffs of Dover
Cult of Personality
We three Kings
Barracuda
Black magic Woman
Cities on flame with rock and roll
Cherub rock
Devil went down to georgia
Even flow
knights of cydonia
la grange
the metal
my name is jonas
mississippi quen
number of the ebast
paint it black
slow ride
rock and roll all night
one
sabotage
welcome to the jungle
sunshine of your love
F.C.P.R.E.M.I.X.

KILL yourself

I liked GH3 alot better, just felt more fun
>tfw used to watch shitty youtube videos of people doing Dragonforce and Devil Went Down to Georgia on Expert

I actually used to draw out the Tom Morello fight for as long as I could because I liked the song

I knew/enjoyed WAY more songs on 3
So my vote goes to GH3

message in a (you)

God Tier:
Rock Band 2
Guitar Hero 3
DJ Hero 1+2
AC/DC Live

High Tier:
Guitar Hero Warriors of Rock
Guitar Hero II
Rock Band 3
Guitar Hero: Metallica

Mid Tier:
Guitar Hero: Rocks the 80s
Guitar Hero 5
Guitar Hero Aerosmith (Totally debatable, I really like Aerosmith)
Guitar Hero
Rock Band
The Beatles: Rock Band (Consider all band games depending on whether you like the band)

Low Tier:
Rock Band 4
LEGO Rock Band
Guitar Hero Live (Points for originality)
Rock Band Blitz/Unplugged (They're just Amplitude)
Guitar Hero World Tour
Guitar Hero Smash Hits
Guitar Hero: On Tour

Shit Tier:
Green Day Rock Band
Guitar Hero Van Halen (Shit even if you liked Van Halen)
Band Hero
Guitar Hero On Tour: Decades
Guitar Hero On Tour: Modern Hits
All Mobile shit

GH5 is shit, don't kid yourself

>putting what is essentially RB1 with different songs in god tier when RB1 itself is much lower
>Move RB3 down a tier or two
>Move GH Metallica up a tier
Solid list otherwise

Outside of being WAY overpriced when it came out, Rock the 80's will forever have the best setlist.

Or Rockband 2.

Fact: 3 has Paint it Black, Rock and Roll All Night, and that awesome remix of Devil Went Down to Georgia.

Fact: 2 does not.

Result: 3 is therefore better than 2.

AC/DC live top tier, lmfao what a crock of shit. Van Halen wasn't even that bad, and RB3 is easily top tier because of custom songs.

Also to whoever said World Tour has a better soundtrack than 2/3, you're an actual cunt

FOR THE LIGHT SOURCE SO WASTED AND GOOOOOONE WE FEEL THE PAIN OF A LIFETIME GONE IN A THOUSAND DAYS THROUGHT THE FIRE AND THE FLAMES WE CARRY OOOOOoooooooooooonnnnnnnn

WT got some good songs like dammit and motherfucking hotel california.

But the entire stuff feels a bit, without salt.


Why GH5 is shit? It is alright but nothing really impressive.

3 is better it's not even a debate

>no Rocksmith 2014 on top of the list
Oh yeah, people playing GH/RB only want to pretend to play guitar.