It is the best ever made? The most realistic? No, but it looks really fucking good and is a blast to play. While not fully realistic, there are actual real sword techniques in Geralt's fighting style, which makes the combat feel more real, and the blood and gore gives it a brutal and visceral feeling. Compare that to FF XV, where the combat looks very absurd, the little emo guy just wildly swings his sword around like a little girl swinging a baton, there's no sense of impact, no blood or gore to give an idea of brutality in the combat. No sense of struggle. Just inane "look how fast and cool it is lol" anime looking shit. It's button mashy, it isn't skillful, it doesn't look or feel fun to play, it's a mess. He just looks really effeminate, and not at all like a fighter.
Are you sure you're not talking about Witcher 3? Witcher 3 has some of the shallowest combat of all time.
Nicholas Nelson
>Witcher 3 has some of the shallowest combat of all time.
You clearly never played it then. It isn't the pinnacle of skill, but it isn't the shallowest either. And FF XV may have the most shallow combat of any rpg I've ever seen. It's like a watered down kingdom hearts/dmc game.
John Baker
>It's button mashy, it isn't skillful, it doesn't look or feel fun to play Could say the same about the Witcher 3.
Isaiah Sanchez
You just posted the same text in the active XV thread fag
Anthony Cooper
I don't know what you mean. It looks like a skilled human fighting a giant suit. It's not devil may cry but that's the point. Looks aesthetically pleasing. I bet the fight would keep you immersed.
Camden Bennett
It's anti-kun is in full meltdown.
Jace Nguyen
>Witcher 3 >fun to play You must be kidding.
Luis Gutierrez
I had more fun with that 15 min demo running at low res sub 20fps than 50 hours of witcher 3.
also, why do you show off w3 gameplay with something as superficial and optional as a compilation of finishers? they can be turned off in options and most of them were added in a later patch anyway
Nathan Gutierrez
i didn't bother reading anything you posted except for the two links. i think xv looks marginally better than the witcher 3 combat wise (and everything else for that matter).
i bet you're one of those faggots who talk about "realism" in video games or something. everything in XV looks like a lot of fun, takes more skill, and overall more badass looking than anything in the shitter tree.
Nathan Cox
...
Ethan Allen
...
Adrian Lewis
Except MGS is a japanese game...?
Elijah Roberts
You fucking wish bro
Dominic Nelson
Of all the combat systems you could have compared it to you chose the Witcher 3, a game where most people agree the weakest aspect is the combat. And you didn't even show off the actual fighting, just a compilation of fancy kill animations.
Mason Davis
FF battle is the main reason i wont buy this game. Fuck its horrible. Witcher is shit tho
Adrian Russell
you can change it to dragon age combat if you want.
Jack Phillips
kill yourself
Zachary Williams
It's almost like OP is just shitposting and/or baiting or something. But OP would never do that, would he?
Samuel Martin
ThatsTheJoke.tiff
Ayden Taylor
>Witcher3 HAHAHahhahah
What's with Witcher3's autistic fanbase? The game doesn't really look that good with its art direction (especially folliage looks like shit), even though the tech is nice, so when I nee Witcher3 VS X game I'm never ever blown off (regardless of how shitty the other game looks) And the same happens with combat, except Witcher3 has even less of an excuse to be compared with ANY other game when it comes to good combat. It's some of the most bland and unfun combat systems out there. Even when you "unfold" all of Witcher3's tactics it still isn't actually FUN to play.
God damn I don't even care all that much for FF15, but you could pick ANY other game, especially now that some of the good games (read: japanese games) are coming to PC. You could compare it with Dragon's Dogma fun combat, or MonsterHunter (even a MH chinese ripoff game is better than Wither3), or a Platinum game, or if we step outside the PC you'd have Bloodborne or NioH
There's a plethora of games, why compare anything to Witcher3: Batman-tier combat? I don't get it.
Is it actual non-ironic autism?
Bentley Cox
Witcherdrone is so desperate that he makes his own thread. Lmao
Witcher 3 combat is all about get Whirlwind as fast as possible and hold square to win.
James Rivera
XV is manlier than anything WItcher 3 could ever hope to do.
All Witcher 3 is some faggot twirling around like a faggot fairy in the most braindead was possible. Noctis is manly as fuck in comparison.
Nicholas Bennett
but witcher is just a glorified porn game
Chase Clark
Really faggot?
Liam Sanders
He's some witchercuck on damage control because he's shitty game is inferior to XV.
Josiah Collins
>whirl is instant win against anything and everything >can chug potions for instant 25% heal >quen
the game is extremely easy even on deathmarch. Awful hitboxes in general too.
I could prepare an optimal set of potions, poison my blade, drink a decoction, set some traps, equip an effective bomb loadout, utilize all of my signs to their fullest extent and time crucial crossbow shots
or i could whirl
Logan Myers
as someone who adores TW 3 (Played through main game twice, both expansions once) the combat is absolutely pedestrian in comparison to the (around 45 minutes) of FFXV that I've played.
Who fucking cares what it looks like, that's personal preference. It fucking plays better.
Samuel Sanchez
The graphic bump did nothing to save the awful combat.
Keep dreaming.
Carter Walker
XV has more depth than any other Action RPG in an open world I've ever seen, with actual proper weight behind you actions, knockback on hits to the enemy, responsive tight controls, W3 is the most braindead trash ever made with a twirly faggot.
Levi Hall
Geralt looks old as fuck and gets his ass canonically kicked many times
Jacob Diaz
The combat in XV is already great and recent stuff show improvements all round. Keep being a shitcunt.
Zachary Wright
>Japs >anime looking Almost like there is some sort of correlation hmm
Anthony Thompson
It's a meme to compare FF15 with W3, just ignore
Ayden Green
If you want manly combat, look at Yakuza Zero. The battles also plays better than anything west has shat out in last decade.
Jonathan Butler
>isn't the shallowest
It's literally Zelda tier combat. It's not bad. It's not good either. It's serviceable.
>Alt >Left click >Alt >Left click >Q sometimes >Shift left click sometimes >Space bar sometimes
It's breddy simple and cal also be stupidly unbalanced.
>Aard build >Aard everything and instakill nearly everything save for a few uncommon/rare monsters or bosses
Ayden Perez
>final fantasy has never had blood or gore >"WHERE IS ALL THE BLOOD AND GORE :(" I don't think this is the game you're looking for.
Jack Cox
>there is a thread on Cred Forums right now where console shitters are comparing 2 shit games and fighting over which one is better
neo-Cred Forums everyone. at least back then people weren't this retarded.
Colton Allen
That's a bug, not a normal fight. Normally you fight that wyvern across the bridge.
Cooper Cruz
The 龍が如く games are basically a homage to brutality. Smashing someone in the face with a bicycle shouldn't be that satisfying but it really fucking is.
Austin Anderson
No, that's a normal fight. Just like this trash.
Nolan James
It's not about Japan, you idiot. It's about FFXV being shit without any coherent vision. They have no idea how to make proper combat and have no people to make it for them.
Austin Williams
Keep dreaming, fag. XV will never be close to Witcher 3's greatness.
Camden Green
>they have no idea how to make proper combat
you know enix made kingdom hearts 2 right
Eli Long
DA:I combat shits on both. And DA:I companions are actually being helpful instead of sliding around looking like a fag.
Owen Green
So? Did they use that combat in FFXV? No. What Tabata wants? To make "hold X for win" shit. KH team now working on KH and FF team keep remaking the combat based on fans feedback simply because they're incapable of doing it themselves.
Andrew Bailey
>They have no idea how to make proper combat Translation: >I don't like the combat therefore it is not proper.
Aaron Perez
Surely, you're joking. that messed up combat system? Good?
Jack Richardson
>DA:I combat
Oliver Williams
Stupid combat is universal. Unless you're a massive XV fag, it's undeniable at this point.
Jackson Jenkins
>DA:I combat shits on both
Mason Hernandez
Imagine identical sets of characters with the same stats. One with DA:I combat, another with XV combat.
Which one will win? I rest my case.
David Powell
>DA:I Are you serious? That's your idea of good combat?
Michael Torres
>Stupid combat is universal. Translation: >I am so autistic that I cannot comprehend that my preferences are not ubiquitous.
Aiden Sullivan
Holy shit HAHAHAHA. OP is actually that desperate to prove that his shitty game is better than XV that he actually has to make a thread about it. Fuck I don't even care about FF15 but the combat already miles better than The Shitter 3.
Grayson Campbell
People who cry about muh realism in video games are the worst kind of trash.
John Sullivan
Same fag doing Double posting.
Juan Roberts
>Who fucking cares what it looks like, that's personal preference.
I do because I don't wanna play as some sissy character flying around like FF XV
Brandon Reed
...
Connor Bennett
Just going for the lowest tier that can beat XV. It's not that hard.
Ethan Young
> >DA:I combat shits on both M8. I actually enjoyed DA:I, but its combat is terrible compared to both TW3 and FFXV.
Jonathan Smith
>both pictures have elf so they're the same person
Colton Myers
it seems as the games release draws closer the shitposting gets worse. I cant imagine what it will be like when it comes out.
Ayden Lewis
It actually comes and goes. There are about two or three really desperate shitposters and one really autistic defender, so when these are asleep the threads are perfectly fine.
Adam White
how have you not realized this is the case for literally any exclusive or any remotely hyped game?
this is fucking NOTHING compared to bloodborne
Charles Gray
I don't quite get what's with XV. At first I thought it might have been just that it -looked- lacking, but upon playing it I still got that it was missing something. It's got hitstop, it's got cancels, it's got appropriate animations for the weapons. Why does it feel clunky and weightless then? What's an average Platinum game have that makes hitting stuff feel good that XV doesn't have? Hell, not even Platinum. Monster Hunter has weapons that feel meaty and powerful on hit, that feel good to pound enemies with, and it doesn't seem to have anything that XV doesn't, in technical terms.
Oh well, at least it's better than the 300-tier SLOMO-normal-SLOMO crap montage OP posted for Witcher 3.
Elijah Watson
Except it is already proven good and it has a coherent vision. They have great combat already and the lead combat designer was from KH2FM battle designer. Nice meme post though.
Holy shit are you fucking serious?
You don't have to hold anything faggot, just like in Smash bros. The combat in XV has already outclassed the combat in KH.
David James
Everyone who's played the latest build all say it's good so no, you are wrong.
Colton Baker
>DA:I combat shits on both. Holy fucking shit i just got into this thread This is one of those magic moments when a statement is so fucking unnaceptable and wrong by any perspective that it becomes actually hilarious
Tbf i don't know those game but i don't think it's possible to make combat any simpler than DAI
Samuel Brown
And lets not forget the nonstop downgrade whinging and JUST shitposting TW3 got. A good chunk of Cred Forums doesn't actually play games; they just whine about them.
Alexander Jones
Here's some improvements that could be made, although I agree that even as it is in the Platinum demo the combat is still better than something like the Witcher 3.
Josiah Hernandez
Except none of that are legitimate and a bunch of shit on that is wrong.
Sebastian Jackson
Like what?
Wyatt Hall
they look both terrible
Mason Perry
I'm not going to bother going through your autism that you repost in multiple threads to try and get people to notice you. Fuck off.
Jeremiah Carter
Auto-actions ruin a lot of the combat. Players not quite being in control of their actions makes it seem like you're on training wheels all the time.
Forget about MH and P* games, even KH2 had significantly more satisfying and high speed gameplay than XV, st least as we've experienced it. We can only hope that eventually the combat will be as snappy as this:
>but it looks really fucking good and is a blast to play
Jaxon Martinez
>even KH2 had significantly more satisfying and high speed gameplay than XV, No it doesn't, you have les combat options in KH. What we've seen of XV recently shows more faster and satisfying hits and combat in XV compared to start game KH2. KH2 only got fast at end game and that is only properly on display against the boss battles with Terra or the Data battles.
Juan Cox
So essential your whole point boils down to "I don't like the hairstyle of this JRPG character" once again.
Owen Richardson
>Witcher >good combat
its literaly the mass effect/risen/generic 3rd person arpg combat with better animations
ff is the same thing but you are flying around the screen instead, and I would argue that leads to far deeper combat due to movement opening up
Like seriously, you are pants on head retarded if you think either have good combat
Its why they are rpgs
Zachary Watson
Nah more like I like combat that feels like fighting, and not a faggy anime ballet circus troupe.
Sebastian Long
>I like combat that feels like fighting >plays the witcher
Thomas Foster
>there is a thread on Cred Forums where people discuss videogames Gee golly, you're right, I should check out on some old Cred Forums classic like twitter or webcomic threads.
Jose Harris
So you don't like Witcher 3 then? Since you just described Witcher 3 as faggy anime ballet circus troupe.