Ico and SoTC

I played Ico only recently but I still like SotC more because muh nostalgia

>unable to defend his shitty games

Shadow of the Colossus is better but Ico is still great

The controls are seriously a non issue, even in TLG

Both are solid good to great depending on your taste. Great artstyle, ost, smart storytelling... Flawed games, but enjoyable : 7 to 8/10.
The thing is : they're solo games and don't have any replay value.

The Last Guardian is something else, its flaws really take prominence over the global experience : 5/10.

>persona reaction image
Say no more

seething

>start an Ico thread
>no replies, only one shitposter
>see this
>100+ replies
Reddit and NeoGaf are unironically better places to discuss videogames

This board is populated by teenagers who haven't played Ico

this, you're going to have better luck on /vr/

We had a nice Ico thread like the day before yesterday. I want to have one now too, what a shame

>start thread about shitty games
>nobody talks about them
woah

Thank you for your time

PS3 remaster, PSCX2 (or whatever it's called) or PS2 original?

Did you know that the castle is near the Forbidden Lands?

PS3 remaster

PS2 version runs at 20 FPS and PCSX2 is shit

PS3 version. I haven't played it but I think PS4 version is the best even though it's basically a new game

The PS3 version is excellent, you get 2 games, not sure about emulation I assume that would vary depending on your specs

These games are not connected

They are. How is that a controversial point?

5 hour game against a 12 hour game.

Gee ...

I hope you're doing that thing

my specs are decent, I can run other stuff on it fine (glitches aside), although I'd rather not run off it because it is a pain. But seeing as the PS3 version is good I'll get that one anyway, thanks fellas.

Yes, they fucking are you cuntsucker.

Don't fuck up by buying only SoTC. Get the bundle that includes both Ico and SoTC and costs just as much

SotC

>Ueda himself stated that they are not
>waah I know better muh gaming theories

>tfw nomad's autism was so powerful that he got credits to a game and was part of an easter egg

...

...

SoTC is better, but it's also a very overrated game.

Last Guardian>Ico>SoTC

13 is the best

This has got to be the holy trinity of overrated fucking games. They're boring and control like shit. And the stories are lame and pretentious. They insist upon themselves way too fucking much. I bet TLG is just as trash.

not that user, but he said in an interview that the world is the same, but the stories aren't connected, so he is right in a way

Did you see the Dunkey video?

Ty brainlet

No, I'm not seven so I don't watch e celebs.

I think so too. Maybe because I could interact with the girl more?

>one is an artsy fartsy escort mission game
>the other is an actual video game where you fight bosses that's also artsy fartsy but doesn't sacrifice gameplay for said artsy fartsiness
Gee, I don't know.

why?

dunkey has shit taste and doesnt think theyre great, what's your point

>doesn't sacrifice gameplay for artsy fartsyness
i saw someone earlier today saying that the games bad control is a metaphor for the protag not being able to come to grips with greif and the fact that he's holding onto grief so it makes sense that controlling him or gripping him would be hard

the game is shit, it controls like shit, and its fans are genuine brainlets that will do mental gymnastics to make it seem like it being "bad on purpose" is a positive. i don't think i've ever seen a single fanbase in this much denial, outside of MAYBE wii u owners and SMTfags.

I liked the gameplay in Ico more desu. SoTC is way too frustrating and irritating, don't even want to replay it

he's the reason why I don't play shit games anymore. plus he's funny

Yeah user because I'd imagine gripping on to a giant fucking behemoth that's trying to shake off would be so easy.

challenge should not come from obtuse controls

How are they obtuse? I grasped everything bar riding standing up right after the first big lad