ITT: Times Pitchfork was wrong

...

Other urls found in this thread:

pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/368-untilted/
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

giving a 10 to:

the bends
kid A
OKC
MBDTF

I really like that album but 9.2 is crazy

trips of truth

for pitchfork standards, I wouldn't be suprised that they gave MBDTF a 10

it got such a high grade because an indie band finally had the guts to be noisy and even a little energetic

...

I've got bad news for you son

I mean Jesus, I haven't even listened to clppng. all the way through and I still know it's better than MBDTF. The fact they seem to be judging basically any record by a black artist by how much they address BLM/social justice politics nowadays kinda baffles me.

not even close to the first record trying to do that

90% Trap albums.

DNA on DNA just a 8.2

Faust a 9.0 and Coloring Book a 9.1

The Kanye West albums
I mean, the guy is ok but MBDTF is not a 10 and Yeezus is nowhere near 9.5, same goes for The Life of Pablo.
I didn't even look at his other scores.

they gave a 10 to The Bends?? lmao, I get OKC and Kid A but The Bends, no way

MBDTF is completely deserved though

should have been lower

>Faust a 9.0

should be a 10

>>Faust a 9.0

>should be a 10
Yup, that was what I was trying to say.

>according to Pitchfork ANOHNI - Hopelessness is at same level of Faust s/t

...

Granted, they're wrong a good deal of the time, but this one and 'In Colour' will live in infamy for me.

oy vey...

every autechre review, the untilted one might be the worst review on p4k

pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/368-untilted/

>MBDTF is completely deserved though

These are all personal 10/10's to me but I agree.

yeah, it should have been a 10.

nice Cred Forums reaction face

not an argument though

get to heaven only getting a 7.2

I'm from Cred Forums though

not like you presented an argument anyway

>album only uses the music to express emptiness and sorrow without relying on ambient filler or people talking about politics
>album flows better than dead flag and antennas
>5.6

This was rated too high. Yanqui U.X.O is better than this, and they rated that album pretty low too.

Yanqui is definitely not better than that. Allelujah is really good. Yanqui ist just good.

yanqui is superior in every way you idiot

gsybe are fucking trash though

anything over 5.0 is charity

this comment is awful

made me chuckle

Yanqui is pretty great. Maybe I'll have another listen to the Allelujah! album, but I remember not enjoying it as much as previous albums.

hdu that is an iconic review

why

hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha thanks for playin'!!

hehe

yeah this is honestly bullshit. the review is nearly kid a level cringe.

allelujah is probably their best with a tie with lysf

i was incredibly happy to see their shift in style when I first heard it

FUCK this one made me mad

This one is just barely overrated. Currents is pretty much a flat 9 for me.

On the other hand, fuck In Colour. Jamie xx makes boring music for boring people.

...

who cares

this was my AOTY 2015

Yankee Hotel Foxtrot is their worst offense in that regard.

...

It should be a 3.5/10

this triggers me

pitchfork has a long track record of being wrong about nine inch nails but these are the worst offenses

for the record I think that these are both very underrated

>MBDTF is completely deserved though

good people

bad people

...

every time they non-ironically use the word "maximalist" to describe a song / band.

should literally be above 8

That's a classic, deserves the 10.

Way too low, but not as good asThis is just plain wrong

this is fucking hilarious