Is this the greatest western ever?

Is this the greatest western ever?

Other urls found in this thread:

imdb.com/title/tt0073594/
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

you're kidding right?

yeah but that's the obvious

One of them. It's hard to decide what the best is considering there are lots of good ones. Best modern era western for sure though.

Westworld is the best western ever, but only people who truly understand all the theories and subplots can appreciate it

No.
But to me it is.

close

John Ford has multiple westerns better than anything ITT.

Also Howard Hawks.

Also Johnny Guitar desu.

This is the correct answer

You guys are fucking peasants.

lawless is better

It's a modern masterpiece

looking forward to whatever Dominik does next.

I thought Stagecoach was incredible, but I really don't get all the hype about The Searchers, nor the the other films I've seen of his.

But what the fuck do I know, most venerable directors would disagree with me.

My Darling Clementine, Liberty Valance, Rio Grande, are great too imho

I saw all those, and the only one that sticks out for me is Liberty Valance.

I have to inform you, of your shit taste, sorry. MDC one of the best black and white films I've seen, certainly one of the most beautifully shot.

Once upon a time in the west.

Nothing is even close to Leone's westerns. Pure 10/10 cinema.

faggoty b8 m8

>Nothing is even close to Leone's westerns
He made great adventure stories but his westerns are pretty thin in theme, characterization, and emotional depth

This and Meek's Cutoff are my favorite modern westerns, hell I have to go to like 50s to find one I like more (Johnny Guitar, The Searchers)

Andrew Dominik can't make a movie with more than a 75% on RT.

This is almost as good as Leone's best works. Anyone who says otherwise, has a shitty taste. Fulci is genius.

imdb.com/title/tt0073594/

Talking westerns and not mentioning based Peckinpah?

> One of the best ever

Anyone seen this? Thoughts?

>tom hardy grunts for two hours

Sadly one of the most underlooked films of recent times

Clearly.

...

Jut because it's universally recognised as the best doesn't mean it's actually not...

Not even the greatest outlaw film Nick Cave has been involved in.

Please.

I just read that he's doing a Cormac McCarthy adaption now I'm hyped as fuck

I really love The Wild Bunch buy my favorite western of his is probably Cable Hogue

...

He's doing cities of the plain and adapting a JCO book too, I don't think anything she has written has been adapted before

on no level is it better