How did anyone think this looked acceptable?

Isaiah Ramirez
Isaiah Ramirez

How did anyone think this looked acceptable?

All urls found in this thread:

youtu.be/fV34mT5m0bM

Dominic Peterson
Dominic Peterson

Yeah, this is the most troubling thing about Star Wars. Not the shitty writing, it's this.

Jason Hernandez
Jason Hernandez

Looks fine to me.

Brandon Hall
Brandon Hall

More life like than he is now.

Nicholas Evans
Nicholas Evans

acceptable? yes perfect? no

Julian Diaz
Julian Diaz

What would you rather have them do? Replace the actor?

Tyler Rivera
Tyler Rivera

It looked fine.

Leia at the end looked wonky though.

Cameron Scott
Cameron Scott

ooked acceptable?

there was something wrong with the way the character moved too , it looked like live actors talking to a video-game character. Leia looked like a corpse.

Jonathan Barnes
Jonathan Barnes

don't make the fucking useless movie
wow we sure do need to explain why the death star has a weakness
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

Nicholas Morales
Nicholas Morales

I think it's mostly due to him being kept in the shadows, which made the effect more passable. Leia was way more lit.

Noah Adams
Noah Adams

He looks like the BFG

Lincoln Hughes
Lincoln Hughes

Reminder that Tarkin looked like this in ROTS

Oliver Smith
Oliver Smith

Looked ok, moved like he had a stick up his ass. Kinda creepy desu

Aaron Price
Aaron Price

which is why we only see his back for like 2 seconds, GL had sense enough not to make him a big character

Cameron Thomas
Cameron Thomas

It was one of the main things that bothered me to no end, they could've just hired an actor that looked similar to Tarkin and either use make up or CGI on his face to make him look like the real thing.

Hudson King
Hudson King

I don't see what's wrong with this

Noah Allen
Noah Allen

That's exactly what they did, retard.

Nicholas Murphy
Nicholas Murphy

Are you aware that in the new canon, Tarkin is gay and let a stormtrooper fuck him in the ass?

Luke Foster
Luke Foster

Just make a new fucking movie with new characters, jesus christ.
It doesnt need to be so and so many years after episode 6.

Parker Hughes
Parker Hughes

let a stormtrooper or ordered a stormtrooper?

Michael Brown
Michael Brown

It's funny how Tarkin looks like 6'4 in Rogue One then shrinks to average height in ANH

Disney doesn't give a shit about anything

Liam Gomez
Liam Gomez

...that is exactly what they did. For him and Leia.

Jose Rodriguez
Jose Rodriguez

do they ever stop complaining?

Lincoln Morgan
Lincoln Morgan

a true method addict

Tyler Adams
Tyler Adams

Let, it was fully consensual

Caleb Wood
Caleb Wood

Acceptable is exactly what it is

Chase Taylor
Chase Taylor

I don't know how they fucked it up so hard, but no doubt Disney only pretends to care about quality. Just look at how right 2049 got it in comparison.

youtu.be/fV34mT5m0bM

Adrian Davis
Adrian Davis

...And then Rachel comes along and blows ILM and Disney away, kek.

Andrew Garcia
Andrew Garcia

underrated

Daniel Ramirez
Daniel Ramirez

it actually checks out
Dear fucking God why why why

Angel Thompson
Angel Thompson

Except that one looked shitty too. All CGI characters in real-time movies look awful because they lack the fluidity of human posture and natural facial expressions. It just looks like bad PS1 cutscenes. Also, how the fuck would they fuck up her eye color? They have footage of her and her fucking DNA file FFS. This movie was so STUPID
Yes, I'm mad.

Elijah Miller
Elijah Miller

I must have actual autism or some sort of faceblindness because this really didn't bother me in the slightest. I actually quite liked Tarkin being in R1, even if he was cgi.

Grayson Lewis
Grayson Lewis

Wow, does Rachel really look like THAT?
No, but seriously, this is actually impressive...

Jacob Sanchez
Jacob Sanchez

Reminder

Christopher Cruz
Christopher Cruz

Yes, I'm mad.

We kinda guessed, faggot.

Matthew Murphy
Matthew Murphy

The techniques used weren't even different.

Aaron Cooper
Aaron Cooper

And 1000% better.

Robert Collins
Robert Collins

Yes, but it was done by a competent team that wasn't used to only animating shitty marvel fight scenes

Christian Perez
Christian Perez

Except MPC actually proof-tested their renders by actually recreating scenes from the original movie, as 's video shows.

ILM has had a really shitty grasp of the relationship between textures and specularity for some time now. They always think "more detail is better", as demonstrated by OP's pic. Another example of this is how terrible Yoda looked in AotC...they actually gave his skin pink subsurface highlights.

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Confirm your age

This website may contain content of an adult nature. If you are under the age of 18, if such content offends you or if it is illegal to view such content in your community, please EXIT.

Enter Exit

About Privacy

We use cookies to personalize content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyze our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our advertising and analytics partners.

Accept Exit