Why wasn't this the next madoka? What went wrong?

Adrian Russell
Adrian Russell

Why wasn't this the next madoka? What went wrong?

Logan Rodriguez
Logan Rodriguez

What went wrong?
it wasn't madoka that what

Jace Powell
Jace Powell

Too much tits

Dylan Wood
Dylan Wood

What went wrong?
Happy ending at all cost formula.

Leo Green
Leo Green

Madoka has it's entire story in 12 episodes. Yuuki Yuuna relies on reading and playing several other materials to understand what's even going on.

Also, Madoka is just better. I don't even love Madoka, but it tells its story a lot better than Yuuki Yuuna.

Andrew Foster
Andrew Foster

Well the Yuuki Yuuna girls are cute than the Madoka girls at least.

Hudson Gomez
Hudson Gomez

Yuna is my Goddess.

Jeremiah Davis
Jeremiah Davis

spends first half doing absolutely fucking nothing
asspull ending

Robert Barnes
Robert Barnes

It kicked too much ass.

Isaac Davis
Isaac Davis

1st half
the Hero Club saves the world
2nd half
discovery that even though they save the world, the Warp Gate that exists just outside the barrier will continually spawn more invaders
resolution
Yuki Yuna becomes the God-Empress of Mankind and PUNCHES THE WARP SO HARD THAT SLANEESH IS KNOCKED THE FUCK OUT

Yuki Yuna's solution was a hell of a lot better than Madoka, who just magically angels herself in right before a mahou shoujo dies so she can take them to yuri avalon. Yuki Yuna fucking SOLVED THE PROBLEM.

Lincoln Young
Lincoln Young

It was better.

Alexander Murphy
Alexander Murphy

As bad as Urobuchi can be, Hackahiro makes him look like Murakami.

Luke Jenkins
Luke Jenkins

What went wrong?
2ch.

Gavin Russell
Gavin Russell

Didnt this sell like 13k

Adam Evans
Adam Evans

tougou pls

Brandon Powell
Brandon Powell

Six years later we still have lengthy threads on Madoka, many awful, but still threads.

Just two years later only the same few circlejerkers ever talk about YYY, Gokumi is dead, and the producers are soliciting gubmint funds for a possible continuation.

Leo Long
Leo Long

shitposters survive the apocalypse

Jeremiah Kelly
Jeremiah Kelly

Every word in this post is wrong.

Evan Edwards
Evan Edwards

was here for the full journey from the bottom of the stalker list to single digits
What a blissful day that was.

Jaxson Robinson
Jaxson Robinson

At least we're still getting content.

Hudson Myers
Hudson Myers

producers are soliciting gubmint funds for a possible continuation
Isn't it the other way? The prefecture is throwing money at gokumi to make more?

Camden Foster
Camden Foster

We have threads regularly every month when the new novel chapter drops. Smart people learn on others' mistakes, and with Madoka threads being as they are, people refrain from making threads unless there's a special occasion.
Don't forget you're comparing a work with Aniplex's marketing budget made by a famous studio with a lot of really big names in the industry involved to a work by Studio Whokumi sponsored by Pony Canyon who has been on a massive flop treak and completely underestimated the popularity of the show to the point where everything kept selling out because of the lack of produced stock.

Dylan Phillips
Dylan Phillips

Yuki Yuna was better.
The characters were actually characters.

Jason Gomez
Jason Gomez

Yuna x Tougou married couple is the best.

John Lee
John Lee

It's better than Madoka.

Jack Morgan
Jack Morgan

Reminder that Yuna is the hero who saved Christmas

Jose Carter
Jose Carter

Nothing is going to be the next Madoka, it is literally the best selling late night anime of this decade and as high as any Otaku-focused Magical Girl will ever get.

This show did well enough by getting decent sales when almost all of the late night magical girls were flopping.

I would make a Saints Row to GTA comparison but I guess that would be Symphogear to Madoka, content, and sales wise.

Gavin Butler
Gavin Butler

There will be a YYY S2; Madoka S2/Movie 4 might never happen if Kizu keeps bombing and Shaft screws up Fate like they did Kagerou.

Bentley Brooks
Bentley Brooks

So when is the Kyoani/Shaft war going to spread to this thread?

Nicholas Rogers
Nicholas Rogers

It didn't know how pace itself, or how to set a proper tone, while having a beach episode in a series that was already only 12 episodes long.

Hudson Bennett
Hudson Bennett

Yuki Yuna is so irrelevant that when the next Madoka movie comes out people will say big boobs rifle user was the one doing Mami's pose. If they manage to remember about YuYuYu's existence, that is.

inb4 muh gunbuster, nobody remembers that either

Aiden Myers
Aiden Myers

Can't be too long, unfortunately. You can't discuss even Your Name without it anymore.

Camden Richardson
Camden Richardson

Madoka S2/Movie 4 might never happen if Kizu keeps bombing and Shaft screws up Fate like they did Kagerou
I don't think that's how it works

Carter Flores
Carter Flores

It wan't shit. That's what happened

Zachary Collins
Zachary Collins

It was one of the most successful shows of its season though. By every metric ut was a big success

Gabriel Sanders
Gabriel Sanders

Kill them all C-Shadow!

Christian Nguyen
Christian Nguyen

Symphogear GX broke 20k
Its a big seller now

Parker Nelson
Parker Nelson

Yes? That is why I said "more comparable sales wise" since the some Saints Row games sold a real fucking lot (despite still being years away from best seller GTA)

Lincoln Cruz
Lincoln Cruz

That's the power of Nana at work.

Luke Gray
Luke Gray

Monthly YuYuYu threads are infinitely better than what Madoka """threads""" have become

Brody Bell
Brody Bell

if Kizu keeps bombing
Stopped reading.

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Confirm your age

This website may contain content of an adult nature. If you are under the age of 18, if such content offends you or if it is illegal to view such content in your community, please EXIT.

Enter Exit

About Privacy

We use cookies to personalize content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyze our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our advertising and analytics partners.

Accept Exit